Every legal system has to answer a basic question: where do its rules come from? This article analyses the origins and classifications of legal principles, that is, the sources from which law is drawn. We first look at what law means. We then study the three main sources of law, customs, precedent and legislation, covering the meaning, essentials and types of each. This topic is a regular question in Jurisprudence papers, so the points are set out in a form that is easy to revise.
1. What is Law?
Law is a set of rules or regulations that are legally binding and apply to everyone in a society. Law has three main purposes:
- To ensure justice: people are treated fairly.
- To resolve conflicts: disputes between people are settled peacefully.
- To maintain order: society runs in a stable and predictable way.
The English philosopher Thomas Hobbes, in his work Leviathan, stressed that without law there is chaos. If there were no binding rules, everyone would act only in their own interest, and conflict would follow.
2. What is Sources of Law?
The sources of law are the origins of legal principles, the places from which legal rules come. They include:
- Customs
- Precedents
- Legislation
- Religion
- Morality
In modern times, judicial decisions (precedents) and legislation are the most significant sources of law. The sections below explain the three main sources in detail.
3. Customs
3.1 Meaning
Customs are long-standing practices followed by a community. Over time, these practices can become legally recognised. In other words, a habit that a community has followed for generations can, in time, become a rule that the law accepts.
In a hypothetical village, families have for generations let their neighbours use a path across their fields to reach the village well. Everyone in the village knows about this practice, and nobody treats it as a secret. If Zoya, a villager, relies on this practice in a dispute, a court may examine whether it meets the essentials of a valid custom given below.
3.2 Essentials of Customs
A practice must have the following features before it can be treated as a valid custom:
- Antiquity: It must have been practised over a long time. ("Antiquity" simply means great age.)
- Public Knowledge: It cannot be secretive. It must be followed openly, so that the community knows about it.
- Reasonableness: It must align with societal norms. An unreasonable practice does not qualify.
- Non-Contradiction with Law: It must not conflict with prevailing legislation. If a custom goes against an existing law, the law prevails.
Remember the four essentials of a custom: Antiquity, Public Knowledge, Reasonableness and Non-Contradiction with Law. If even one is missing, the practice does not qualify as a valid custom.
3.3 Types of Customs
- Without Sanctions: Practices that people follow voluntarily. No legal consequence follows if someone does not follow them. (A "sanction" here means the backing of law that makes a rule enforceable.)
- With Sanctions: Legally recognised customs. These are further divided into:
- Legal Customs: Customs that are accepted by courts.
- Conventional Customs: Customs that are binding within agreements, because the parties have agreed to be bound by them.
Farhan and Aadil are traders in a hypothetical market. They sign an agreement that adopts a usage long followed among traders in that market. That usage binds them because it forms part of their agreement. This is a conventional custom.
4. Precedent
4.1 Meaning
Precedents are judicial decisions that are used as a guide for future cases. They are especially important in a hierarchical legal system, that is, a system in which courts are arranged in ranks, from lower courts up to higher courts.
4.2 Essentials of Precedent
- Binding Nature: Lower courts follow the decisions of higher courts.
- Hierarchy: The weight of a precedent depends on the rank of the court that gave it.
- Judge-Made Law: Judges expand and interpret legal principles. This is why precedent is often called "judge-made law".
Suppose a higher court decides a legal question in one case. Later, Neha files a case in a lower court that raises the same legal question. Because lower courts follow the decisions of higher courts, the lower court judge will follow the earlier ruling while deciding Neha's case.
4.3 Types of Precedent
- Ratio Decidendi: The reasoning behind a judgment. It is binding. The Latin phrase means "the reason for the decision".
- Obiter Dicta: Judicial observations. They are only persuasive, which means a later court may take them into account but does not have to follow them. The Latin phrase means "things said by the way".
An easy way to remember the difference: the ratio decidendi is the reasoning that decides the case, so it binds. Obiter dicta are remarks made by the way, so they only persuade.
5. Legislation
5.1 Meaning
Legislation means creating formal laws through recognised authorities. It is one of the most significant sources of law, because the rules it produces are written down, formal and authoritative.
5.2 Essentials of Legislation
- Legal Backing: It is created by recognised authorities.
- Formal Procedures: It is enacted through specific processes.
- Recognition: It is widely accepted by institutions.
5.3 Types of Legislation
- Supreme Legislation: Law enacted by Parliament or other sovereign authorities.
- Subordinate Legislation: Rules made by authorities to whom law-making power has been delegated (handed down). It includes:
- Autonomous Law
- Judicial Rules
- Local Laws
- Colonial Law
- Executive-Made Rules
Parliament passes a hypothetical Act on public health. This is supreme legislation. The Act allows a local body to make rules on waste disposal in its area. If Renu is fined for breaking those local rules, she has been fined under subordinate legislation (a local law), which draws its authority from the parent Act.
Summary
Customs, precedents and legislation together form the backbone of any legal system:
| Source | Role | Key types |
|---|---|---|
| Customs | Provide a traditional basis for law | Without sanctions; with sanctions (legal and conventional) |
| Precedent | Guides judicial interpretation | Ratio decidendi (binding); obiter dicta (persuasive) |
| Legislation | Gives formal and authoritative legal rules | Supreme; subordinate |
Customs provide a traditional basis, precedents guide judicial interpretation, and legislation ensures formal and authoritative legal rules. Together, these sources maintain order and justice in society. For exams, remember the meaning, essentials and types of each source. Also remember that, in modern times, judicial decisions and legislation are the most significant sources of law.