When a tort is committed, the person who suffers harm naturally asks: what can I do about it? Tort law answers this question through remedies. A remedy is the legal means by which a wronged person gets relief. This article explains the two broad groups of remedies, judicial and extra-judicial, and each remedy within them. Short examples are added along the way to help you understand and remember them for your exams.
Judicial and Extra-Judicial Remedies
In tort law, remedies are the means through which the rights of an aggrieved party (the person who has been wronged) are restored after a tort has been committed.
The main goal of tort remedies is to put the injured party back in the position they were in before the tort occurred. This can be done in different ways. The right way depends on:
- the nature of the harm, and
- the circumstances surrounding it.
There are two main categories of remedies in tort law:
- Judicial remedies, which are given by a court.
- Extra-judicial remedies, which the aggrieved party can take without going to court.
| Basis | Judicial remedies | Extra-judicial remedies |
|---|---|---|
| Who provides the remedy | The court | The aggrieved party, through their own action |
| Nature | A legally enforceable remedy given through the legal system | Self-help that the law permits in certain situations |
| When used | When the aggrieved party seeks redress through the legal system | When immediate action is necessary |
| Main types | Damages, injunction, specific restitution of property | Expulsion of trespasser, re-entry on land, re-caption of goods, abatement of nuisance, distress damage feasant |
Judicial Remedies for Torts
Judicial remedies are the most common form of redress (relief for a wrong) in tort law. They involve the intervention of the courts. When an aggrieved party seeks redress through the legal system, the court provides a remedy that is legally enforceable. This means the defendant can be compelled by law to obey it.
Judicial remedies can be classified into three main types:
- Damages
- Injunction
- Specific Restitution of Property
1. Damages
Damages are monetary compensation awarded by the court to the aggrieved party. Their purpose is to restore the aggrieved party to the position they were in before the tort occurred.
The basic principle behind awarding damages is to fully compensate the claimant for their loss, as far as money can do so. Damages are the primary remedy in tort cases. They aim to cover the following kinds of harm suffered by the plaintiff:
- financial harm,
- physical harm, or
- emotional harm.
Aadil carelessly drives into Zoya's parked car and damages it. Zoya can sue Aadil and ask the court to award damages so that she gets the money needed to put her back where she was before the accident.
Types of Damages:
- Nominal Damages: These are awarded when the plaintiff's legal rights are violated, but no actual loss or damage is suffered. The word "nominal" means "in name only". The award mainly recognises that a right was violated.
- Contemptuous Damages: These are awarded when the court recognises that the plaintiff's rights were violated, but believes that the lawsuit was trivial or unnecessary.
- Compensatory Damages: These damages are meant to compensate the plaintiff for the actual loss suffered.
- Aggravated Damages: These are awarded when the harm suffered by the plaintiff is particularly severe, including emotional distress.
- Punitive Damages: These are also known as exemplary damages. They are awarded to punish the defendant for particularly egregious (shockingly bad) conduct.
- General and Specific Damages: General damages compensate for non-monetary harm. Specific damages cover quantifiable losses, that is, losses that can be measured exactly in money.
Constantine v. Imperial London Hotels Ltd: The plaintiff was denied service based on nationality. He was awarded nominal damages. His legal right had been violated even though he had not proved any actual loss.
Neha is injured in an accident caused by Hansa's fault. Her hospital bills and her lost salary can be calculated exactly, so they fall under specific damages. Her pain and suffering cannot be measured exactly in rupees, so compensation for it falls under general damages.
Remoteness of Damage: In tort law, the concept of remoteness deals with whether the damage suffered by the plaintiff is a direct consequence of the defendant's actions. In simple words, the court asks whether the harm is closely enough connected to the defendant's act. If the damage is too "remote" (too far removed) from the act, it may not be compensated.
2. Injunction
An injunction is an equitable remedy. "Equitable" means that the remedy comes from principles of fairness, and the court gives it in its discretion. An injunction is a court order directing a party:
- to do a specific act, or
- to refrain from doing (not do) a specific act.
Injunctions are used when monetary damages are not enough to remedy the harm. Injunctions can be:
- Temporary (Interim) Injunctions: These are granted to maintain the status quo (the existing state of affairs) until the case is finally decided.
- Permanent (Perpetual) Injunctions: These are issued as a final order. They permanently prohibit or require certain actions by the defendant.
Prince begins cutting trees on land that Farhan claims as his own. While the case is pending, the court may grant a temporary injunction stopping Prince from cutting more trees, so that the situation stays as it is. If Farhan wins at the end of the case, the court may grant a permanent injunction.
M/S. Hindustan Pencils Pvt. Ltd. v. M/S. India Stationery Products: The court granted an interim injunction to prevent the defendant from infringing the plaintiff's trademark.
3. Specific Restitution of Property
Specific restitution means restoring to the plaintiff property that was wrongfully taken or withheld. This remedy is used when the plaintiff's property rights have been infringed. Here, the court orders the return of the property itself rather than monetary compensation.
Renu lends her family's old sewing machine to Farhan. He later refuses to return it. Renu values the machine itself, not its price. She can ask the court to order Farhan to give back the machine.
Damages give money. An injunction gives an order to do or not to do something. Specific restitution gives back the property itself.
Extra-Judicial Remedies for Torts
Extra-judicial remedies allow an aggrieved party to remedy the harm through their own action, without the intervention of the courts. "Extra-judicial" simply means "outside the court".
These remedies are available in situations where:
- immediate action is necessary, and
- the law permits the aggrieved party to act in their own defence.
There are five main extra-judicial remedies:
- Expulsion of Trespasser
- Right of Re-entry on Land
- Right of Re-caption of Goods
- Abatement of Nuisance
- Distress Damage Feasant
1. Expulsion of Trespasser
A person has the right to use reasonable force to expel (throw out) a trespasser from their property. This right depends on two conditions:
- the person must have a legal entitlement to possess the property, and
- the person must use only the necessary amount of force to remove the trespasser.
Prince enters Aadil's shop and refuses to leave after being asked to go. Aadil may use reasonable force, such as firmly leading Prince out of the door. He may not beat Prince, because that would be more force than necessary.
2. Right of Re-entry on Land
This remedy allows the owner of a property to re-enter it and take possession if someone has unlawfully taken over the property.
Zoya returns from a long trip and finds that Farhan has unlawfully occupied her empty house. Under this remedy, Zoya may re-enter her house and take back possession.
3. Right of Re-caption of Goods
"Re-caption" means "taking back". If someone unlawfully takes possession of another person's goods, the owner has the right to reclaim the goods using reasonable force.
This remedy is different from judicial restitution because it does not require court intervention.
Neha sees Hansa riding away on Neha's bicycle without permission. Neha may stop Hansa and take back her bicycle using reasonable force, without first going to court.
4. Abatement of Nuisance
"Abatement" means removing or reducing something. Abatement of nuisance is the right to remove or stop a nuisance without going through the courts.
Branches from Renu's tree grow over the wall into Aadil's courtyard and block it. Aadil may remove the overhanging branches himself to stop the nuisance, instead of filing a case.
5. Distress Damage Feasant
"Damage feasant" means "doing damage". This remedy applies when a person's livestock or animals trespass onto another person's land and cause damage. The landowner has the right to seize the animals and keep them until compensation for the damage is paid.
Prince's goats stray into Zoya's field and eat her crops. Zoya may seize the goats and keep them until Prince pays compensation for the damaged crops.
| Remedy | What it allows |
|---|---|
| Expulsion of Trespasser | Removing a trespasser with reasonable and necessary force |
| Right of Re-entry on Land | Re-entering and taking back property that someone has unlawfully taken over |
| Right of Re-caption of Goods | Taking back one's own goods with reasonable force |
| Abatement of Nuisance | Removing or stopping a nuisance without going to court |
| Distress Damage Feasant | Seizing trespassing animals until compensation for the damage is paid |
Conclusion
In tort law, the main goal of remedies is to restore the injured party to the position they were in before the tort occurred.
Judicial remedies, such as damages, injunctions and specific restitution, involve the court's intervention to ensure that justice is done. Extra-judicial remedies, on the other hand, allow individuals to protect their rights without needing to go to court.
Judicial remedies provide a formal and structured way to address grievances. Extra-judicial remedies offer immediate relief in certain situations. However, extra-judicial remedies can be used only in specific circumstances. They must be exercised within the bounds of the law to avoid liability.
Self-help is not a licence to use excessive force. A person who goes beyond what the law permits while using an extra-judicial remedy may become liable themselves.
Understanding these remedies is important for anyone involved in a tort case. They show the different ways available to seek redress and help ensure that justice is achieved.