Skip to content
The Law Easy
Law of Torts Case compilation

Law Of Tort Important Case Law

35 min read Published Updated 864,606 views

Cover: Law Of Tort Important Case Law

Watch the lecture

Chairman, Railway Board v. Chandrima Das (2000) | Article 21 for Foreigners | PIL Case Law

On this page

Introduction

The Law of Torts in India is largely judge-made. Most of its basic ideas come from a small group of famous judgments, both English and Indian. These include what counts as a legal injury, when consent is a defence, when a person is liable even without any fault, and when the State must pay for the wrongs of its servants. The same cases are asked again and again in LL.B. semester examinations, judiciary examinations and other law exams.

This article collects the most important tort cases in one place. For each case you will find:

  • Topic: the doctrine or principle the case is cited for;
  • Facts: what happened, in simple words;
  • Held: what the court decided; and
  • Principle: the one idea you should remember and write in your answer.

This first part begins with the basic maxims of tort law. It then covers consent, negligence, medical negligence, nervous shock, defamation, strict and absolute liability, the liability of the State and inevitable accident. It ends with the Wagon Mound case on remoteness of damage. The article then continues with further leading cases.

Key Latin maxims at a glance

Several Latin maxims appear in this part. Learn their plain meaning first, because examiners often ask you to explain a maxim with the help of a case.

MaximPlain meaningCases in this part
Injuria Sine DamnoViolation of a legal right without actual loss or damageAshby v. White; Bhim Singh v. State of J&K; Municipal Board of Agra v. Asharfi Lal
Damnum Sine InjuriaActual loss or damage without violation of any legal rightGloucester Grammar School; Mayor & Co. of Bradford v. Pickles; Town Area Committee v. Prabhu Dayal; P. Seetharamayya v. Mahalakshmamma
Volenti Non Fit InjuriaTo a willing person, no injury is done (consent as a defence)Lakshmi Rajan v. Malar Hospital Ltd.; Haynes v. Harwood; Hall v. Brooklands Auto Racing Club; Smith v. Charles Baker & Co
Res Ipsa LoquiturThe thing speaks for itselfMunicipal Corporation of Delhi v. Subhagwanti

1. Ashby v. White (1703) – Injuria Sine Damno

Topic: Injuria Sine Damno. Injuria means the violation of a legal right. Damnum means actual loss or damage, such as loss of money, health, comfort or property. Injuria sine damno therefore means “legal injury without actual damage”.

Facts: The plaintiff was a qualified voter at a parliamentary election. The defendant, a returning officer, wrongfully refused to take the plaintiff’s vote. The refusal caused the plaintiff no loss, because the candidate he wanted to vote for won the election anyway.

Held: The court applied the maxim Injuria Sine Damno. There was a violation of the plaintiff’s legal right, even though no physical damage was done to him.

Principle: Once a legal right is violated, the person can sue even if he has suffered no real loss.

Example

Prince is a registered voter in a municipal election. The presiding officer, Farhan, wrongly turns him away from the polling booth. Prince’s candidate wins comfortably anyway, so Prince has lost nothing in money or result. His legal right to vote has still been violated, so under Injuria Sine Damno he can sue.

2. Bhim Singh v. State of J&K AIR 1986 – Injuria Sine Damno

Topic: Injuria Sine Damno; violation of the fundamental right to personal liberty.

Facts: The police wrongfully detained Bhim Singh, an M.L.A. of the J&K Assembly, while he was going to attend the Assembly session. He was not produced before the Magistrate within the required period. This violated his fundamental right to personal liberty guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution.

Held: By the time the Supreme Court decided the petition, Bhim Singh had already been released. Even so, the Court gave him consequential relief, meaning relief that follows from the finding that his right had been violated. It awarded him damages amounting to Rs. 50,000 for the breach of his legal right.

Principle: Releasing the person later does not wipe out the wrong. The illegal detention itself is a violation of a legal right, for which damages can be awarded.

3. Municipal Board of Agra v. Asharfi Lal AIR 1921 – Injuria Sine Damno

Topic: Injuria Sine Damno; the right to vote.

Facts: The concerned authorities wrongfully deleted the name of the plaintiff, Asharfilal, from the voters’ list. Because of this, he could not cast his vote.

Held: The plaintiff’s legal right to vote had been violated, so he was entitled to compensation.

Principle: This case, like Ashby v. White, shows that the right to vote is a legal right. Wrongfully preventing a person from exercising it is a legal injury (injuria) for which compensation can be claimed.

4. Gloucester Grammar School (1410) – Damnum Sine Injuria

Topic: Damnum Sine Injuria, meaning “damage without legal injury”. A person may suffer real loss, but if no legal right of his has been violated, he cannot sue.

Facts: A schoolmaster set up a school in competition with the plaintiff’s school. Because of the competition, the plaintiff had to reduce its fees from 40 pence to 12 pence per quarter (a period of three months). The plaintiff claimed compensation from the defendants for this loss.

Held: The plaintiff had no remedy. The defendant’s act, though morally wrong, had not violated any legal right of the plaintiff.

Principle: Loss caused by competition, without the violation of a legal right, gives no claim in tort. A moral wrong is not the same as a legal wrong.

Example

Aadil runs a successful coaching centre in Lucknow. Farhan opens a similar centre on the same street with better teachers, and many of Aadil’s students move to him. Aadil has to cut his fees and suffers a heavy loss (damnum). Farhan has not violated any legal right of Aadil (no injuria), so Aadil cannot claim compensation.

Key point

Injuria Sine Damno: legal right violated, no loss, so the plaintiff can sue (Ashby v. White). Damnum Sine Injuria: loss suffered, no legal right violated, so the plaintiff cannot sue (Gloucester Grammar School). In tort, the violation of a legal right matters more than the loss.

5. Mayor & Co. of Bradford v. Pickles 1895 – Damnum Sine Injuria

Topic: Damnum Sine Injuria.

Facts: The plaintiff was an organization that distributed water to the people it served. It filed a suit against the defendant for constructing a well on his own land. The plaintiff said the well obstructed the flow of water to the plaintiff’s land. This caused the plaintiff monetary loss, because there was a scarcity of water to distribute to the people it served.

Held: The court applied the doctrine of Damnum Sine Injuria. The plaintiff was not entitled to compensation, because the defendant had not caused any wrongful loss or violated any legal right of the plaintiff.

Principle: A person who does a lawful act on his own land does not commit a tort merely because his neighbour suffers a loss.

6. Town Area Committee v. Prabhu Dayal AIR 1975 – Damnum Sine Injuria

Topic: Damnum Sine Injuria; demolition of an illegal construction.

Facts: The plaintiff constructed 16 shops on the old foundations of a building. He did not:

  • give a notice of intention to erect a building, as required under Section 178 of the U.P. Municipalities Act; or
  • obtain the necessary sanction (permission) required under Section 180 of that Act.

The defendants demolished this construction. The plaintiff sued them for compensation. He argued that their action was illegal because it was mala fide, that is, done in bad faith.

Held: The defendants were not liable, because no “injuria” could be proved. If a person constructs a building illegally, its demolition by the municipal authorities does not cause “injuria” to the owner of the property. The plaintiff suffered damage, but the defendant caused him no legal injury. This is the legal maxim damnum sine injuria.

Principle: A person has no legal right to keep an illegal construction. Its removal by the proper authority may cause loss, but it is not a legal injury.

7. P. Seetharamayya v. Mahalakshmamma 1958 – Damnum Sine Injuria

Topic: Damnum Sine Injuria; the right of a landowner to protect his land from water.

Facts: Four defendants tried to keep water from a stream from flowing into their plot. They dug a trench and put up a bund (a raised earthen wall or embankment that holds back or turns away water) on their lands. The fifth defendant, acting independently, also put up bunds on her land to stop water flowing onto it. As a result of these acts, rainwater now flowed onto the plaintiffs’ land and damaged it. The plaintiffs asked for:

  1. a mandatory injunction (a court order directing a person to do a positive act) to demolish the bunds and fill up the trench on the defendants’ lands;
  2. a permanent injunction (an order forbidding a person, for all time, from doing an act) to stop the defendants from making such bunds or trenches; and
  3. damages of Rs. 300 for the loss already caused by the flow of water to their land.

Held: The High Court held that the owner of land on or near a river has a right to build a fence on his own ground to prevent damage from the river’s overflow. This is so even if the overflowing water is then diverted to the neighbour’s land and damages it. This was a clear case of Damnum Sine Injuria, so the defendants were not liable for the harm to the plaintiffs.

Principle: Protecting one’s own land is a lawful act. The neighbour may suffer damage, but none of his legal rights is violated.

Topic: Free consent; medical negligence; Volenti Non Fit Injuria. The maxim means “to a willing person, no injury is done”. A person who freely consents to an act or a risk cannot later complain of harm from that act or risk. The defence works only within the limits of the consent actually given.

Facts: The complainant, a married woman aged 40 years, noticed a painful lump developing in her breast. The lump had no effect on her uterus. Yet during the surgery, her uterus was removed without any justification.

Held:

  • The opposite party, i.e., the hospital, was liable for deficiency in service. (“Opposite party” is the party against whom a consumer complaint is filed. “Deficiency in service” means a fault or shortcoming in the quality of a service.)
  • The patient’s consent to the operation did not mean she consented to the removal of her uterus.
  • Volenti non fit injuria did not apply, because the patient had not consented to the removal of the uterus.

Principle: Consent to one act is not consent to a different act. Consent to one surgery does not allow the doctor to do another, unrelated procedure.

Example

Neha signs a consent form for the removal of one decayed tooth. While she is under anaesthesia, the dentist also removes two healthy teeth. Her consent covered only the decayed tooth, so the dentist cannot rely on volenti non fit injuria for removing the healthy teeth.

9. Haynes v. Harwood 1935 – Volenti Non Fit Injuria

Topic: Volenti Non Fit Injuria; the position of a rescuer.

Facts: The defendant’s servant left a horse van unattended in a street. The horses bolted (ran off suddenly) and put women and children on the road in danger. A police constable managed to stop the horses, but he was injured in doing so.

Held: The policeman had taken the risk voluntarily. Even so, he was entitled to compensation, because he had acted to rescue women and children. Volenti non fit injuria was not applied, because his act was treated as a duty to rescue.

Principle: A rescuer who takes a risk to save people from a danger created by the defendant is not treated as a “willing” person, so the defence fails. The position is the same when a person takes a risk to rescue property from a danger created by the defendant.

10. Hall v. Brooklands Auto Racing Club 1932 – Volenti Non Fit Injuria

Topic: Volenti Non Fit Injuria; spectators at sporting events.

Facts: The plaintiff was a spectator at a car racing event held on a track belonging to the defendant. During the race, two cars collided, and one was thrown among the people watching. The plaintiff was injured.

Held: The plaintiff knowingly undertook the risk of watching the race. Anyone watching such an event could foresee this type of injury. Volenti non fit injuria was applied, and the defendant was not held liable.

Principle: A spectator who chooses to watch a dangerous sport is taken to accept the risk of the kind of injury that can be foreseen at such an event.

11. Smith v. Charles Baker & Co 1891 – Volenti Non Fit Injuria

Topic: Volenti Non Fit Injuria; knowledge of risk is not consent.

Rule: Knowing about a risk is not the same thing as agreeing to run that risk. The maxim is Volenti Non Fit Injuria (“to a willing person, no injury is done”). It is not scienter non fit injuria (“to a knowing person, no injury is done”). Knowledge of danger does not necessarily mean consent to bear that danger.

Facts: The injured person was drilling rocks at a place where a crane was lifting heavy stones over his head. Both he and his employers knew there was a risk of stones falling. However, he was not warned of the exact time the lifting would begin. A stone fell from the crane and injured him.

Held: The House of Lords held the defendants liable. Mere knowledge of the risk did not mean consent.

Principle: A worker who continues working while knowing of a danger does not, for that reason alone, agree to suffer injury from it.

Example

Renu works in a factory in Surat. She knows that the safety guard on one machine is loose and has complained about it. She keeps working because she needs the job. If she is injured by that machine, the employer cannot argue that her knowledge of the danger amounted to her consent.

Key point

For volenti non fit injuria, the plaintiff must have agreed to the risk, not merely known about it. Remember: volenti, not scienter.

12. T.C. Balakrishnan Menon v. T.R. Subramanian 1968 – Non-Natural Use of Land

Topic: Non-natural use of land. This means using land for a special and dangerous purpose, as opposed to its ordinary use. The idea is closely connected with the rule of strict liability discussed in Rylands v. Fletcher (Case 23 below).

Held: The use of explosives in a maidan (open ground), even on a festival day, is a non-natural use of land. Under the Indian Explosives Act, licences must be taken from the prescribed authorities for making and storing explosive substances, even at such places and on such occasions. The court applied the non-natural use of land doctrine, and the defendant was held liable for any harm that could be caused.

Principle: A festival or a public occasion does not make the use of explosives an ordinary use of land. A person who brings such dangerous things onto land is liable for the harm they cause.

13. Donoghue v. Stevenson 1932 – Duty of Care, Duty Towards Neighbour, Negligence

Topic: Negligence; duty of care; duty towards one’s “neighbour”. Negligence, in simple words, is the failure to take the care that the law requires, which causes harm to another. A duty of care is a legal obligation to take reasonable care not to harm others. The “neighbour” idea means that this duty is owed to persons who are likely to be directly affected by one’s acts.

Facts: The appellant plaintiff drank from a bottle of ginger beer that her friend had bought from a retailer. The bottle was made of dark, opaque glass, so its contents could not be seen. It in fact contained the decomposed body of a snail. She found this out only after she had already drunk part of the contents.

Held: The manufacturer was responsible for his negligence towards the plaintiff. Note that the plaintiff had not bought the bottle herself; her friend had. According to Lord Atkin:

“A manufacturer of the products, which he sells in such a form as to show that he intends them to reach the ultimate consumer in the form in which they left him with no reasonable possibility of intermediate examination and with the knowledge that the absence of reasonable care in the preparation or putting up of the products will result in an injury to the consumer’s life or property, owes a duty to the consumer to take that reasonable care.”

In simple words, a manufacturer owes the consumer a duty to take reasonable care when:

  1. he sells the product in a form showing that he intends it to reach the ultimate consumer in the same form in which it left him;
  2. there is no reasonable possibility of the product being examined in between (for example, by the shopkeeper); and
  3. he knows that a lack of reasonable care in preparing or packing the product will result in injury to the consumer’s life or property.
Example

Hansa buys a sealed packet of biscuits from a shop and gives it to her neighbour, Zoya. Zoya finds a piece of metal inside and is hurt while eating. The packet was sealed, so the shopkeeper could not have checked it. On the Donoghue v. Stevenson principle, the manufacturer owed Zoya a duty of care, even though Zoya did not buy the packet herself.

14. Municipal Corporation of Delhi v. Subhagwanti 1966 – Negligence, Res Ipsa Loquitur

Topic: Negligence; Res Ipsa Loquitur. The maxim means “the thing speaks for itself”. It applies where the very nature of an accident suggests negligence by the person in control of the thing that caused it. The defendant then has to explain how the accident happened without negligence on his part.

Facts: A clock tower in Chandni Chowk, Delhi, collapsed and caused the death of several people. The plaintiffs, who were heirs of the deceased, filed suits for damages. They alleged that the Municipal Committee had been negligent in maintaining the structure.

Held: The trial court and the High Court found in favour of the plaintiffs. They applied the doctrine of Res Ipsa Loquitur and held the Municipal Corporation liable for the damages.

Principle: When a structure under the control of an authority collapses, the collapse itself can point to negligence in maintenance. The authority can then be held liable.

15. Malay Kumar Ganguly v. Sukumar Mukherjee 2010 – Medical Negligence

Topic: Medical negligence.

Facts: Anuradha Saha, the wife of Dr. Kunal Saha, was treated in Kolkata by the respondent doctors for a skin rash. She died in May 1998. One doctor had prescribed a steroid injection beyond the maximum recommended dose. Dr. Kunal Saha claimed compensation for medical negligence.

Held: The Supreme Court held that the hospital and several of the treating doctors had been negligent. It sent the case back to the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (the highest consumer forum in India) only to decide the amount of compensation.

Principle: Giving a medicine beyond its maximum recommended dose is the kind of conduct for which doctors and hospitals can be held liable for medical negligence.

16. Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab 2005 – Medical Negligence

Topic: Medical negligence; the Bolam principle. In simple words, the Bolam principle (from an English case) says a doctor is not negligent if he acted in line with a practice accepted as proper by a responsible body of doctors skilled in that field.

This is a landmark judgment of the full bench of the Supreme Court of India. It decided the issue of medical negligence in line with Bolam’s Principle.

Facts:

  • The appellant doctor was called to attend to a patient in a hospital who was having difficulty in breathing.
  • The doctor connected an oxygen cylinder to the patient’s mouth, but the breathing problem grew worse. The cylinder was later found to be empty.
  • No other gas cylinder was available in the room. The patient’s attendant brought a cylinder from the adjoining room himself, but there was no arrangement to make it work.
  • The patient died in this chaos. A complaint was registered under Section 304-A of the IPC (causing death by negligence).
Note

Section 304-A of the IPC applied when this case was decided. Causing death by negligence is now dealt with under Section 106 of the B.N.S. The IPC section is kept here because it explains the judgment.

Held: The Supreme Court observed that no sensible professional would intentionally do or omit anything that would cause loss or injury to the patient, since the professional’s own reputation is at stake. The Court held that a doctor must:

  • exercise a reasonable degree of care for his patient; and
  • bring to his task a reasonable degree of skill and knowledge.

Principle: The law expects a doctor to show reasonable care, skill and knowledge, judged in line with the Bolam principle. It does not expect the highest possible degree of care.

17. Hambrook v. Stokes Bros 1924 – Nervous Shock

Topic: Nervous shock. This means mental or psychological harm caused by a sudden shock, as opposed to bodily injury. Damages may be claimed for it in tort.

Facts: A lady had just parted from her children when she saw a lorry running violently down a steep and narrow street. She was frightened for her children’s safety. A bystander then told her that a child matching the description of one of her children had been injured. She suffered nervous shock, which resulted in her death. The defendants had negligently left the lorry unattended.

Held: The court recognised an action for nervous shock, even though the plaintiff had no fear of physical injury to herself, only fear of injury to her children. The defendants were held liable, although the lady who suffered the shock was not herself within the area of physical injury.

Principle: A claim for nervous shock can arise from fear for the safety of one’s children, even when the person was not personally in danger.

18. Bourhill v. Young 1942 – Nervous Shock

Topic: Nervous shock; duty of care and foreseeability (whether a reasonable person could have expected the harm).

Facts: The plaintiff, a fishwife (a woman who sells fish), was getting out of a tramcar when she heard an accident. She could not see it, because she was about 50 feet away and the tramcar blocked her view. A negligent motorcyclist had been killed in the accident. After his body had been removed, she went to the scene and saw blood on the road. As a result, she suffered nervous shock and gave birth to a stillborn child (a baby born dead). She sued the personal representatives of the motorcyclist, that is, the persons who legally represent a dead person’s estate.

Held: The House of Lords held that the deceased could not be expected to foresee any injury to the plaintiff. He therefore owed her no duty of care, and his personal representatives could not be made liable.

Principle: A defendant is liable for nervous shock only if he owed a duty of care to the plaintiff. Here there was no such duty, because injury to her could not be foreseen.

Key point

Compare the two nervous shock cases. In Hambrook v. Stokes Bros, the defendants were liable even though the mother was outside the area of physical injury. In Bourhill v. Young, there was no liability, because the motorcyclist could not foresee any injury to the plaintiff and so owed her no duty of care.

19. Newstead v. London Express Newspapers Ltd 1940 – Defamation

Topic: Defamation, which means harming a person’s reputation by publishing a false statement about him; and the question of whom the statement refers to.

Facts: The defendants published an article saying that “Harold Newstead, a Camberwell man,” had been convicted of bigamy (marrying again while a lawful earlier marriage still exists). The story was true of one Harold Newstead, a Camberwell barman. But the action for defamation was brought by another Harold Newstead, a Camberwell barber.

Held: The words were held to be understood as referring to the plaintiff, so the defendants were held liable.

Principle: What matters is whether the words would be understood as referring to the plaintiff. A statement that is true about one person can still defame another person of the same name.

20. Union Carbide Corporation v. Union of India – Absolute Liability

Topic: Absolute liability (see Case 21 for its meaning); the Bhopal gas tragedy.

Facts: The Bhopal gas tragedy is, to this day, the world’s worst industrial disaster. It occurred in December 1984 at Bhopal in Madhya Pradesh. Methyl isocyanate (MIC) gas leaked from the pesticide plant of Union Carbide India Ltd (UCIL) on a night in December 1984. People all around the city of Bhopal were exposed to the gas. Its immediate effects included:

  • coughing;
  • vomiting;
  • severe eye irritation; and
  • a feeling of suffocation.

Thousands of people died.

Outcome: The case did not end with a court applying “Absolute Liability”. In 1989 the Supreme Court recorded a settlement under which Union Carbide paid US$ 470 million for the benefit of all the victims, “not as fines, penalties or punitive damages”. In 1991 the Court left the settlement undisturbed.

Note

Do not write in an exam that the Bhopal case laid down absolute liability. The rule of “Absolute Liability” was laid down in M.C. Mehta v. Union of India (the oleum gas case, below). The Bhopal case ended in a settlement.

21. M.C. Mehta v. Union of India AIR 1987 – Absolute Liability

Topic: Absolute liability. This is liability for harm caused by an extremely dangerous activity. It applies whether or not there was any negligence or intention, and it allows no defences.

Facts: Poisonous oleum gas leaked from one of the units of Shriram Foods and Fertiliser Industries in Delhi, and several people were injured.

Held: The defendant was absolutely liable for the damage caused, whether or not there was any negligence or intention. Under this rule of absolute liability, none of the defences available under the strict liability rule can be used. The court said, “A person who carries on such an extremely dangerous activity is responsible for any harm that may flow from such activity.”

Key point

Strict liability (Rylands v. Fletcher): liability without negligence, but some defences are available. Absolute liability (M.C. Mehta v. Union of India): liability without negligence or intention, and the defences available under strict liability are not available.

22. M. P. Electricity Board v. Shail Kumar AIR 2002 – Strict Liability

Topic: Strict liability of an electricity supplier.

Facts:

  • On a rainy night, a workman was cycling home from the factory.
  • Heavy rain had covered the road completely with water, and nothing on the road was visible.
  • A snapped live electric wire was lying on the road. It was being used by one person (the 3rd Respondent), who was secretly stealing electricity for his own home without the Electricity Board’s knowledge.
  • The workman could not see the wire and came into contact with it. He died instantly from electrocution.

An action was brought against the M.P. Electricity Board.

Held: The Supreme Court held that the Electricity Board had a statutory duty (a duty imposed by law) to supply electricity in the area. If the electricity it transmits injures or kills a person who gets trapped in it unknowingly, the supplier is strictly liable.

Principle: A supplier of a dangerous thing like electricity is strictly liable for injury or death caused by it to persons who come into contact with it unknowingly.

23. Rylands v. Fletcher 1868 – Strict Liability

Topic: Strict liability, meaning liability even without negligence.

Facts: The defendant built a huge reservoir on his land to supply water to his mill. He did not know that there were some unused mineshafts just next to his reservoir. The water burst through the reservoir into the shafts and flooded the plaintiff’s coal mines on the adjoining land.

Held: The defendant was held liable. The court reasoned that a person is responsible, even if he was not negligent, when:

  1. he brings a potentially dangerous thing onto his land;
  2. that thing escapes; and
  3. it causes damage.
Example

Aadil stores a large tank of chemical waste on his farm in Punjab. The tank bursts without any carelessness on his part, and the waste flows into Prince’s fields and destroys his crops. Under the rule in Rylands v. Fletcher, Aadil can be held liable even though he was not negligent.

24. The Madras Railway Company v. Zemindar of Carvatengarum 1874 – Strict Liability

Topic: Strict liability; natural user of land.

Facts: The railway company had built a culvert (a channel or tunnel that carries water under a road or railway line) to carry water from the railway track to a nearby river. The culvert discharged the water onto the Zemindar’s land and damaged his crops. The Zemindar sued the railway company for compensation for the damage.

Held: The Privy Council held that the railway company did not have an absolute right to discharge the water onto the Zemindar’s land, even under the principle of natural user. The railway company had to take reasonable precautions to prevent damage to the Zemindar’s land. If it failed to do so, it could be held liable for the damage caused.

Principle (as stated in this article): Even a natural use of land does not give an absolute right to send water onto a neighbour’s land. Reasonable precautions must be taken to prevent damage.

25. State of Rajasthan v. Vidhyawati 1962 – Sovereign Function, State Liability

Topic: Liability of the State for the wrongs of its servants; sovereign function. “Sovereign functions” are functions that only the State, as the sovereign power, can perform. “Sovereign immunity” is the defence that the State is not liable for wrongs committed while performing such functions.

Facts: The State of Rajasthan employed a driver as a temporary employee and posted him under the Collector. After the car had been repaired, the driver was driving it back along a public road. He knocked down a pedestrian walking on the footpath, causing multiple injuries that resulted in death. The plaintiff sued the State for compensation.

Held: The court held the Rajasthan Government liable for the acts of its servant done in the course of employment (while doing the work he was employed to do). These acts and functions were similar to those of any other employer. The defence of sovereign immunity was rejected.

Principle: When the State acts like an ordinary employer, it is liable for its servants’ wrongs in the same way as a private employer.

26. Kasturilal Ralia Ram Jain v. State of U.P 1965 – Sovereign Function

Topic: Sovereign function; immunity of the State.

Facts: Ralia Ram came to Meerut to sell gold, silver and other goods in the market. As he passed through the bazaar with his goods, three police constables took him into custody. His belongings were seized, and he was detained. He was later released and his silver was returned, but he could not recover the gold. He sued the State.

Held: The police officers had been negligent in dealing with property they had seized while exercising their statutory power (power given by law). This was a sovereign function, so the State was not held liable for the appellant’s loss caused by the negligence of the police.

Principle: In this case, the Supreme Court held that the State is not liable for the negligence of its servants committed in the exercise of sovereign functions. Compare this with Vidhyawati (Case 25) and with N. Nagendra Rao & Co. (Case 29), where the Supreme Court said courts should discard this exemption.

27. Stanley v. Powell 1891 – Inevitable Accident

Topic: Inevitable accident. This is an accident that could not have been prevented by taking reasonable care. It is a defence in tort.

Facts: During a pheasant shoot (a hunt for game birds), the plaintiff was carrying cartridges and game. A shot fired by the defendant bounced off a tree and hit the plaintiff.

Held: Applying the principle of inevitable accident, the court decided that the defendant was not responsible for the accident.

Principle: A defendant is not liable for harm that results from an inevitable accident.

28. Chairman, Railway Board v. Chandrima Das 2002 – Sovereign Function, State Liability

Topic: State liability; Article 21 rights of foreign citizens.

Facts: Railway employees gang-raped a Bangladeshi woman on Railway premises.

Held: The Supreme Court held that the victim, although a foreign citizen, was entitled to the protection of the right to life under Article 21 of the Constitution. The Central Government was held liable to pay compensation to the victim, and the defence of sovereign immunity was rejected.

Principle: Article 21 protects every person, not only Indian citizens. The State cannot hide behind sovereign immunity when its employees commit such a grave wrong.

29. N. Nagendra Rao & Co. v. State of A.P. 1994 – Vicarious Liability of the State

Topic: Vicarious liability of the State. “Vicarious liability” means liability of one person for a wrong done by another, such as an employer’s liability for wrongs done by an employee in the course of employment.

Held: The Supreme Court made the following points:

  • The liability of the State should be recognised by statute (law made by the legislature).
  • The rule exempting the State from liability should be done away with.
  • In the interest of social justice in a welfare state, Indian courts should discard the rule exempting the State from liability on the ground of sovereign function.

Principle: In a welfare state, the State should be answerable for the wrongs of its servants like any other employer. The old sovereign function exemption should not stand in the way of justice.

Key point

For an exam answer on State liability, trace this line of cases: Vidhyawati (State liable as an ordinary employer), Kasturilal (State not liable, sovereign function), Chandrima Das (sovereign immunity rejected, compensation under Article 21) and N. Nagendra Rao (courts should discard the sovereign function exemption).

30. Overseas Tankship (U.K.) Ltd. v. Morts Dock and Engg. Co. Ltd. 1961 [Wagon Mound Case] – Remoteness of Damage

Topic: Remoteness of damage. Remoteness deals with how far down the chain of consequences a defendant remains liable. Damage that is “too remote” is not compensated. Under the test of reasonable foresight, a defendant is liable for the damage that a reasonable person in his position could have foreseen.

Held (main rule): The test of reasonable foresight is the better test.

Facts:

  • The Wagon Mound, an oil-burning ship, was chartered (hired) by the appellants, Overseas Tankship Ltd. It was taking on fuel oil at Sydney port.
  • Because the appellants’ servants were negligent, a large quantity of oil spilled onto the water.
  • About 60 hours later, molten metal from the respondent’s wharf (a platform where ships load and unload) fell on floating cotton waste.
  • The burning waste set fire to the fuel oil on the water, causing great damage to the wharf.

Decision: The Supreme Court of New South Wales held O.T. Ltd. liable. On appeal, the decision was reversed by applying the test of reasonable foresight.

Principle: A negligent defendant is not liable for every consequence of his act. He is liable only for the damage that passes the test of reasonable foresight.

Hughes v. Lord Advocate 1963

Topic: Remoteness of Damages

Remoteness of damages asks how far a wrongdoer's liability goes. Not every loss that follows a wrongful act can be charged to the defendant. Some losses are too 'remote', meaning too distant or unexpected, to be recovered. This case shows how courts decide which losses are close enough to the wrongful act to be compensated.

Facts

  • Post office employees opened a manhole to maintain underground telephone equipment.
  • The manhole was covered with a tent.
  • One evening it was left with paraffin lamps around it, but otherwise no one was guarding it.
  • A child of eight years entered the tent and started playing with one of the lamps.
  • The lamp fell into the manhole and caused a violent explosion. The boy also fell into the hole and suffered severe injuries.

Judgment

The House of Lords held the defendants liable. The kind of damage was foreseeable, even though its extent was not.

Key point

The defendant is liable if the kind of damage was foreseeable. It does not matter that the extent of the damage was not foreseeable. Read this case together with Overseas Tankship (U.K.) Ltd. v. Morts Dock and Engg. Co. Ltd., discussed earlier in this article.

Example

A contractor engaged by Prince leaves an open, unguarded pit with a burning stove beside it on a busy lane in Lucknow. Farhan, a young boy, plays near it, knocks the stove into the pit and is badly burnt in a much bigger fire than anyone expected. Burn injury to a child was the kind of harm one could foresee, so the larger-than-expected extent of the injury would not, on the reasoning in Hughes, save the defendant from liability. (Hypothetical example.)

Nichols v. Marshland

Topic: Act of God

An Act of God is an event caused by natural forces, such as an extraordinary storm, flood or earthquake. It is so unusual that no reasonable human care or foresight could have guarded against it. When the loss is caused by such an event and not by the defendant's lack of care, the defendant may escape liability.

Facts

  • The defendant built three artificial lakes, fed by a natural stream.
  • The lakes were well constructed and adequate in all normal circumstances.
  • An extraordinary rainfall burst the banks of the artificial lakes on the defendant's property.
  • The flood water destroyed a number of bridges owned by the county council.

Judgment

The court held that the defendant was not negligent. The accident was due to an Act of God.

Key point

The lakes were properly built and were enough for normal conditions. The rainfall was extraordinary, so the loss was caused by an Act of God and not by any fault of the defendant.

Example

Aadil builds a well-designed water tank on his farm in Rajasthan, strong enough for all normal monsoon rains. A rare and extraordinary cloudburst breaks the tank, and the water damages Zoya's adjoining field. If Aadil had taken proper care in building the tank, he could rely on the reasoning in Nichols v. Marshland and argue that the loss was due to an Act of God. (Hypothetical example.)

Smith v. Leech Brain & Co Ltd 1961

Topic: Remoteness of Damages (Eggshell Skull Rule)

The eggshell skull rule means that a wrongdoer must take the victim as he finds him. If the victim has a hidden weakness, such as a 'skull as thin as an eggshell', and therefore suffers far more harm than an ordinary person would, the wrongdoer is still liable for the full harm. The defendant cannot argue that a healthier person would have suffered less.

Facts

  • The complainant worked for the defendants, Leech Brain & Co Ltd, as a galvanizer of steel.
  • While he was operating a machine at the workplace, a piece of molten metal burnt his lip.
  • The burn was treated, but he later developed cancer and died three years later.
  • He already had a pre-cancerous condition before the burn took place.

Judgment

The defendants were held negligent and liable for damages to the complainant. The court applied the eggshell skull rule. The defendants were liable for the full extent of the injury, even though the complainant had a pre-existing condition.

Key point

A pre-existing weakness of the victim does not reduce the wrongdoer's liability. If some harm (here, a burn) was foreseeable, the defendant is liable for the full harm that actually followed because of the victim's condition.

Example

Because of Neha's careless driving, her scooter lightly hits Hansa. An ordinary person would only have been bruised. However, Hansa has a rare bone condition and suffers a serious fracture. Applying the eggshell skull rule, Neha would be liable for the whole injury, not just a bruise. (Hypothetical example.)

Note

Compare the two remoteness cases in this part. In Hughes v. Lord Advocate, the extent of the damage was unforeseeable. In Smith v. Leech Brain & Co Ltd, the victim's own condition made the harm greater. In both cases, the defendant remained liable because the kind of harm was foreseeable.

Conclusion

The cases in this article cover the core ideas of the Law of Torts that students meet again and again in exams:

  • Injuria sine damno and damnum sine injuria: violation of a legal right versus actual loss (Ashby v. White, Bhim Singh, Gloucester Grammar School, Bradford v. Pickles and others).
  • Volenti non fit injuria and consent (Haynes v. Harwood, Hall v. Brooklands, Smith v. Charles Baker & Co, Lakshmi Rajan).
  • Negligence and medical negligence (Donoghue v. Stevenson, Jacob Mathew, Malay Kumar Ganguly) and nervous shock (Hambrook v. Stokes Bros, Bourhill v. Young).
  • Strict and absolute liability (Rylands v. Fletcher, M.C. Mehta, Union Carbide, M.P. Electricity Board v. Shail Kumar).
  • Liability of the State (Vidhyawati, Kasturilal, N. Nagendra Rao, Chandrima Das).
  • Defences and remoteness of damages (Stanley v. Powell, Nichols v. Marshland, Overseas Tankship, Hughes v. Lord Advocate, Smith v. Leech Brain).

For revision, link each case to its topic, remember its key facts in two or three lines, and state its rule in one sentence. This method helps you write clear, case-backed answers in LL.B. and judiciary examinations.

Practise Law of Torts MCQs

123 questions. Every answer comes with an explanation and the legal provision behind it.

Practise now

Make this page yours

Sign in to save your reading progress and keep private notes and highlights. Free, and only you can see them.

Keep reading

Related notes

Law of Torts Complete notes

Law Of Torts One Shot

Meaning: A tort is a civil wrong, distinct from a crime or breach of contract, for which the law provides a remedy, typically unliquidated damages.

78 min read

Law of Torts

Concepts and Essentials of Torts

Understanding the fundamentals of tort law Introduction A tort is defined as a wrong independent of a contract that leads to a civil remedy, allowing for compensation recovery. The word "tort" comes from the Latin term…

8 min read

Law of Torts

Remedies for Torts

In the realm of tort law, remedies are the means through which the rights of an aggrieved party are restored after a tort has been committed. The primary goal of tort remedies is to return the injured party to the posit…

9 min read

Law of Torts

Malicious Prosecution

Malicious prosecution is a legal concept under the Law of Torts that protects individuals from baseless and malicious legal actions. It occurs when someone intentionally and without just cause initiates legal proceeding…

8 min read

Law of Torts

Concept of Defamation under Law of Torts

Defamation in the Law of Torts refers to harming a person’s reputation through false statements. According to Section 499 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) 1860, defamation occurs when someone makes or publishes a false st…

9 min read

Watch

Related lectures