A contract is valid only when the people who make it have the legal capacity to do so. Some people are able to understand a contract perfectly well, yet the law still stops them from entering into agreements, either fully or only in certain matters. These people are called persons disqualified by law. This article explains each of these categories in simple terms: alien enemies, convicts, insolvents, joint companies and corporations, and foreign sovereigns and ambassadors. It also covers the cases that explain each rule and gives short examples to help you remember them in the exam.
Persons Disqualified by Law
Understanding the Legal Implications and Restrictions
A disqualification by law means that the person's capacity to contract is limited because a legal rule says so, not because of any defect in that person's mind or age. Each category below has its own reason, its own limits and, in some cases, its own exceptions.
Alien Enemies
An alien is a person who is not a citizen of India. An alien enemy is someone from a country that is at war with India.
The rules on alien enemies can be broken down as follows:
- During wartime, contracts with alien enemies are void. A void contract is one that has no legal effect at all and cannot be enforced by either party.
- Prior approval is required. Such contracts cannot be made without prior approval from the Indian government.
- Alien friends are treated differently. Contracts with alien friends are valid. Alien friends are people from countries that have a friendly or neutral status with India.
Thus, alien enemies are disqualified by law from entering into agreements.
Prince, an Indian trader, agrees to supply machinery to Farhan, a national of a country that is at war with India. Prince does not get any approval from the Indian government. Because Farhan is an alien enemy and the contract is made during wartime without government approval, the contract is void. On the other hand, if Prince makes the same contract with Zoya, a national of a country that is friendly or neutral towards India, the contract is valid, because Zoya is an alien friend.
Feroza Begum and Ors. v. Dewan Daulat Rai Kapoor and Ors.
In this case it was observed that under Section 83 of the Code of Civil Procedure, "Alien enemies residing in India with the permission of the Central Government, and alien friends, may sue in any Court otherwise competent to try the suit as if they were citizens of India. However, alien enemies residing in India without such permission or residing in a foreign country shall not sue in any such court."
In simple words, Section 83 of the Code of Civil Procedure creates the following positions:
- Alien friends may sue in a competent Indian court as if they were citizens of India.
- Alien enemies living in India with the permission of the Central Government may also sue as if they were citizens of India.
- Alien enemies living in India without such permission cannot sue in such a court.
- Alien enemies living in a foreign country cannot sue in such a court.
For an alien enemy, permission from the government is what matters. Contracts during wartime need prior approval from the Indian government, and the right to sue under Section 83 of the Code of Civil Procedure depends on residing in India with the permission of the Central Government.
Convicts
A convict is a person who has been found guilty of a crime and sentenced by a court. Under the rule explained here, individuals who have been sentenced to death or life imprisonment by a competent court are disqualified from entering into contracts while they are serving their sentences.
The main features of this disqualification are:
- It applies to persons sentenced to death or life imprisonment by a competent court.
- It lasts only while the sentence is being served.
- Once the sentence is completed, or the person is pardoned, the disqualification is lifted.
Aadil is sentenced to life imprisonment by a competent court. Under the rule described above, he cannot enter into a contract to sell his shop while he is serving his sentence. If Aadil is later pardoned, the disqualification is lifted and he can enter into contracts again.
This concept of disqualification for convicts was removed by the Criminal Justice Act of 1948.
Insolvents
An individual is considered insolvent if they cannot cover their debt balance with available cash. In other words, the person owes more than they are able to pay. Insolvents are disqualified by law from entering into certain contracts.
Two terms are useful here:
- Official receiver: the officer who takes control of the insolvent person's property.
- Order of discharge: the order that releases the insolvent person from the insolvency proceedings.
The insolvent person's capacity to contract depends on whether an order of discharge has been passed:
| Stage | What the insolvent person can do | What the insolvent person cannot do |
|---|---|---|
| Before an order of discharge | Enter into specific contracts, such as incurring debts or purchasing property | Sell their property, which is under the control of the official receiver |
| After an order of discharge | Regain their contractual capacity | The regained capacity does not extend to their property |
Neha has been declared insolvent and no order of discharge has yet been passed. She can still take a small loan or buy a scooter. However, she cannot sell her flat, because her property is under the control of the official receiver.
Vraj Kuwar Bai v. Kunjbiharilal Krishna Chandra
It was held that the term "property" refers to the personal property of an insolvent, which they can dispose of at will.
Banarasi Das v. Bhagat Ram
It was held that trust property held by an insolvent is not considered their property.
Read together, these two cases tell us which "property" is affected by insolvency. Property that belongs to the insolvent personally, and which they can dispose of at will, is covered. Property that the insolvent holds only as a trustee for someone else is not treated as their property.
Insolvency also brings some other disabilities. Insolvents cannot serve as:
- magistrates;
- directors of companies; or
- members of local bodies.
Even so, they retain their contractual capacity except with respect to their property.
Joint Companies and Corporations
A company or corporation is an artificial person. This means it is not a human being, but the law creates it and treats it as a person that can hold rights and duties. Because the law creates it, its powers are also limited by law.
- A company or corporation can only enter into contracts within the scope of its Memorandum of Association (the document that sets out the company's objects and powers) or the provisions of the special Act under which it is created.
- Within these limits, a registered company can enter into contracts in its own name; it can also sue and be sued in that name.
- Thus, they are disqualified by law when contracting outside the powers conferred upon them.
Hansa Textiles Ltd. is a company whose Memorandum of Association allows it to manufacture and sell cloth. If the company signs a contract to manufacture cloth, it acts within its powers. If it signs a contract for a business that falls completely outside the powers conferred by its Memorandum of Association, it is disqualified by law from making that contract.
Foreign Sovereigns and Ambassadors
A foreign sovereign is the ruler or head of a foreign State, and an ambassador is the official representative of a foreign State in India. The law gives them a special position:
- They can contract and sue: foreign sovereigns and ambassadors can enter into contracts and sue to enforce contracts in Indian courts.
- They cannot ordinarily be sued: they cannot be sued in Indian courts unless they voluntarily submit themselves to the court or have approval from the Central Government.
- Privileged position: they are generally considered privileged, but this privilege protects them from being sued; it does not make them incompetent to contract.
Renu, a supplier in Delhi, agrees to supply furniture to the ambassador of a foreign country. If Renu fails to deliver, the ambassador can sue Renu in an Indian court to enforce the contract. But if the ambassador fails to pay, Renu cannot sue the ambassador in an Indian court unless the ambassador voluntarily submits to the court or there is approval from the Central Government.
So, foreign ambassadors are also persons disqualified by law from entering into agreements.
Conclusion
Certain individuals are disqualified by law from entering into contracts under specific circumstances and are not competent to contract. This includes alien enemies, convicts, insolvents, joint companies, corporations, foreign sovereigns, and ambassadors. These rules ensure that contracts are entered into with individuals who have the legal capacity to fulfil their obligations.
For quick revision, remember the main idea behind each category:
- Alien enemies: contracts during wartime are void without prior approval from the Indian government; alien friends can contract validly.
- Convicts: persons sentenced to death or life imprisonment are disqualified while serving their sentence, until it is completed or they are pardoned.
- Insolvents: they keep their contractual capacity except with respect to their property.
- Companies and corporations: they can contract only within their Memorandum of Association or special Act.
- Foreign sovereigns and ambassadors: they can sue but ordinarily cannot be sued without voluntary submission or Central Government approval.