Harvey v. Facey: Case Summary - Contract Law Principles
Understanding the fine line between an offer and an invitation to treat
Published Updated 94,533 views
On this page
Facts
Harvey wanted to buy a property called Bumper Hall Pen, which belonged to Facey. Harvey asked Facey whether he would sell the property and asked him to state the lowest price.
Facey replied: "Lowest price for Bumper Hall Pen: £900."
Harvey treated this reply as an offer and accepted it. Facey, however, refused to sell. Harvey claimed that a contract had been formed.
Issues
1. Was Facey's price quote an offer?
2. Did Harvey's reply accepting the price create a valid contract?
Arguments
For Harvey (buyer): Facey's reply stating the lowest price was an offer, so Harvey's acceptance completed a binding contract.
For Facey (seller): The reply was only a response to an inquiry giving information about the price. It was not an offer to sell.
Judgment
The court ruled in favour of Facey.
No offer: Facey's reply was an invitation to treat, not an offer, because it lacked a clear intention to be legally bound.
No contract: Since there was no offer, Harvey's reply could not be an acceptance, and no valid contract came into existence.
Legal principles
1. Merely quoting a price, even the lowest price, is not an offer. It is an invitation to treat (an invitation to negotiate).
2. A valid contract requires a clear offer and a clear acceptance of that offer.
3. An offer must show a clear intention to be legally bound. Without such intention, a statement is only an invitation to treat.
4. An "acceptance" of an invitation to treat does not create a contract; at most it can itself be an offer.
Relevant provisions
Indian Contract Act, 1872 – Section 2(a) (proposal); Indian Contract Act, 1872 – Section 2(b) (acceptance and promise)
Importance
Harvey v. Facey is a standard case for the distinction between an offer and an invitation to treat, a topic regularly asked in exams. Under the Indian Contract Act, 1872, Section 2(a) requires that a proposal show willingness to do or abstain from doing something with a view to obtaining assent. Facey's reply lacked that intention, so it was not a proposal. Under Section 2(b), only a proposal that is accepted becomes a promise; without a proposal, there can be no promise or contract. Students use this case to explain why price quotations, catalogues and similar statements usually do not bind the person making them.
Easy explanation
Harvey wanted to buy Facey's property. He asked Facey if he would sell it and what the lowest price was. Facey only said the lowest price was £900. Harvey said, "I accept," but Facey would not sell.
The court said Facey had only given information about the price. He had not promised to sell. Telling someone a price is like opening the door to bargaining, not making a final offer. Because there was no offer, Harvey had nothing to accept, so there was no contract.
Practical example
Hypothetical: Prince messages Farhan, "Will you sell me your old car? What is the lowest price you would take?" Farhan replies, "Lowest price: Rs. 2 lakh." Prince replies, "I accept, the car is mine." Farhan then decides not to sell. Applying Harvey v. Facey, Farhan only quoted a price; he did not show a clear intention to be bound. His reply is an invitation to treat, so Prince's "acceptance" does not create a contract. Prince's message may at most be treated as an offer, which Farhan is free to reject.
Key points
- Quoting a price, even the lowest price, is an invitation to treat, not an offer.
- Facey's reply "Lowest price for Bumper Hall Pen: £900" lacked intention to be legally bound.
- No offer means no acceptance and no contract.
- A valid contract needs a clear offer and a clear acceptance.
- Indian link: Section 2(a) (proposal) and Section 2(b) (acceptance/promise) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.
⚖️ Harvey v. Facey: Case Summary ⚖️
Understanding the fine line between an offer and an invitation to treat
📌 Introduction
The case of Harvey v. Facey is a cornerstone in contract law, clarifying the distinction between an offer and an invitation to treat. It established that merely quoting a price does not amount to an offer but is an invitation to negotiate.
📜 Facts
- Parties: Harvey (buyer) and Facey (seller).
- Dispute:
- Harvey inquired if Facey would sell a property and requested the lowest price.
- Facey replied: "Lowest price for Bumper Hall Pen: £900."
- Harvey accepted this "offer," but Facey refused to sell.
- Claim: Harvey argued that Facey’s price quote was an offer.
- Defense: Facey contended it was merely a response to an inquiry, not an offer.
⚖️ Legal Issues
- Was Facey’s price quote an offer?
- Did Harvey’s reply create a valid contract?
🏛️ Judgment
No Offer: The court ruled that Facey’s reply was an invitation to treat, not an offer, as it lacked a clear intent to be legally bound.
No Contract: Since there was no offer, there was no valid acceptance or contract.
📚 Key Legal Principles
- Invitation to Treat: Quoting a price is not an offer.
- Offer and Acceptance: A valid contract requires a clear offer and acceptance.
- Intention: A contract needs clear intent to create legal relations.
📖 Relevance to Indian Law
Under the Indian Contract Act, 1872:
- Section 2(a): Facey’s response lacked the intent to make a proposal.
- Section 2(b): Without an offer, no promise or contract exists.
🔍 Conclusion
The case emphasizes the necessity of distinguishing between an offer and an invitation to negotiate, forming a crucial principle in contract law.
📝 Legal concepts made simple for better understanding! ⚖️
Test yourself on this case
1 practice question on this case, with explanations.
Harvey telegraphed to Facey: 'Will you sell us Bumper Hall Pen? Telegraph lowest cash price.' Facey replied: 'Lowest price for Bumper Hall Pen, nine hundred pounds.' Harvey then telegraphed that he agreed to buy at that price, but Facey never replied. According to the decision of the Privy Council, what was the legal position?
More Law of Contract I (General Principles) MCQs
115 questions. Every answer comes with an explanation and the legal provision behind it.
Make this page yours
Sign in to keep private notes and highlights on this case. Free, and only you can see them.