Skip to content
The Law Easy

Acceptance under Indian Contract Act 1872

17 min read Published Updated 907,005 views

Cover: Acceptance under Indian Contract Act 1872
On this page

Every contract starts with a proposal (also called an offer) and is completed by its acceptance. Until the offer is accepted, there is no contract and nobody is bound. That is why acceptance is one of the most important, and most frequently examined, topics in Law of Contract I.

According to the Indian Contract Act 1872, acceptance is the final and unqualified expression of assent to the terms of a proposal. In simple words, acceptance means saying a clear and complete “yes” to the offer exactly as it was made. Acceptance must be given in the manner and within the time specified in the proposal, or if no time is specified, within a reasonable time.

In this article you will study the definition of acceptance under Section 2(b), the conditions for a valid acceptance, its types, how and when acceptance is communicated, the postal rule, the place of acceptance, acceptance by telephone or telex, and the leading cases on each point: Felthouse v Bindley, the case of Mr. Powell's appointment as headmaster, Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Company, Household Fire and Carriage Accident Insurance Company v Grant, Adams v Lindsell, Bhagwan Das v Girdgari Lal and Hyde v. Wrench.

Definition of Acceptance (Section 2(b))

Section 2(b) of the Indian Contract Act 1872 defines acceptance in these words:

“When the person to whom the proposal is made signifies his assent thereto, the proposal is said to be accepted. A proposal, when accepted, becomes a promise.”

Before going further, remember four basic terms used throughout this topic:

  • Proposer (offeror): the person who makes the proposal or offer.
  • Offeree (acceptor): the person to whom the proposal is made and who accepts it.
  • Assent: agreement or consent.
  • Signifies: shows or makes known to the other side.

So, the definition can be read in three simple steps:

  1. A proposal is made to a particular person (the offeree).
  2. That person shows his agreement to it.
  3. The proposal is then “accepted” and turns into a promise.
Example

Prince offers to sell his old bicycle to Hansa for ₹3,000. Hansa replies, “Yes, I agree to buy your bicycle for ₹3,000.” Hansa, the person to whom the proposal was made, has signified her assent. Prince's proposal is accepted and has now become a promise.

Valid Acceptance Criteria

An acceptance is valid only when the following conditions are met:

  • Given by the Person to Whom the Proposal is Made: The acceptance must be made by the person to whom the proposal was addressed. A stranger to the proposal cannot accept it.
  • Given in the Manner Prescribed: Acceptance must follow the manner specified by the proposer. If the proposer has asked for a particular method of reply, that method must be used.
  • Given within the Time Prescribed: Acceptance must be communicated within the time specified in the proposal or within a reasonable time.
  • Absolute and Unqualified: The acceptance must be unconditional and unequivocal, that is, without any condition attached and without any doubt about its meaning.

If acceptance is not given within the prescribed time, it is considered invalid, and the proposer is no longer bound by the proposal. If acceptance is not given in the prescribed manner, the proposer may, within a reasonable time after the acceptance is communicated to him, insist that it be given in the prescribed manner; if he does not do so, he accepts the acceptance (Section 7).

Types of Acceptance

Acceptance can be of two types:

  • Express Acceptance: Given through words or writing.
  • Implied Acceptance: Given through the conduct of the offeree.
Example

Zoya offers to design a website for Farhan for ₹20,000. If Farhan writes back by email, “I accept your offer,” this is express acceptance, because it is given in writing. If, instead, Farhan's actions clearly show that he has agreed to Zoya's terms, his acceptance is implied from his conduct. Acceptance by conduct is explained in detail later in this article.

Communication of Acceptance

“Acceptance must be communicated” is a fundamental principle of contract law. For a contract to be legally binding, the acceptance of a proposal or offer by the offeree must be communicated to the proposer or offeror. A decision to accept that stays only in the offeree's mind does not create a contract.

  • Communication Methods: Acceptance can be communicated through any reasonable means, such as writing, orally (by spoken words), or through conduct.
  • Timing and Conditions: The communication must be made within a reasonable time and must be absolute and unconditional.

Failure to communicate acceptance means no contract is formed, and the offeror is not bound by the offer. Therefore, it is essential for the offeree to communicate their acceptance within a reasonable time to form a legally binding contract.

Landmark Case Law

Two well-known cases explain why acceptance must be communicated. The first shows that silence is not acceptance; the second shows that acceptance must be communicated by an authorised person.

Felthouse v Bindley

Facts: Paul Felthouse, the complainant, discussed buying a horse from his nephew, John Felthouse. After their conversation, Paul wrote a letter to his nephew stating that if he did not hear anything further regarding the horse, he would consider the purchase agreed upon and would own the horse. John did not reply to this letter and was busy with auctions. The defendant, Mr. Bindley, was running the auctions, and John instructed him not to sell the horse. However, Mr. Bindley accidentally sold the horse to someone else.

Issues: Paul Felthouse sued Mr. Bindley for the tort of conversion. (Conversion is a civil wrong in which a person deals with another person's goods as if they were his own, for example by selling them.) To succeed, Paul had to prove that the horse was his property and that a valid contract existed. The central issue was whether silence or failure to reject an offer could constitute acceptance.

Decision / Outcome: The court held that there was no contract for the horse between Paul Felthouse and his nephew. The court ruled that silence did not amount to acceptance, and an obligation cannot be imposed on someone by another person. Acceptance of an offer must be clearly communicated. Despite the nephew's intention to sell the horse to Paul and the nephew's interest in the sale, there was no binding contract because the nephew did not explicitly accept the offer. Therefore, the nephew's failure to respond did not constitute acceptance of the offer.

Case

Felthouse v Bindley: Silence does not amount to acceptance. The offeror cannot impose an obligation on the offeree by saying that, if he does not reply, his silence will be treated as acceptance.

Example

Renu writes to Prince: “I will buy your laptop for ₹25,000. If I do not hear from you by Friday, I will treat the laptop as mine.” Prince does not reply. Following Felthouse v Bindley, Prince's silence is not acceptance, and there is no contract between Renu and Prince.

Case Study: Mr. Powell's Appointment as Headmaster

Facts: Mr. Powell, the plaintiff, was a candidate for the position of headmaster at a school. The manager referred his candidature to the appointing authority, which subsequently passed a resolution to appoint him to the position. However, no formal acceptance was communicated directly to Powell; these were internal discussions only. One of the managers, who had not been authorised by the others to do so, informed Powell of the decision. Powell was pleased with the news, but later, the board members decided to cancel the resolution appointing him. Consequently, Powell filed a suit against the managers for breach of contract.

Issues: The primary issue before the court was whether there was an actual breach of contract as claimed by the plaintiff.

Judgement: The court ruled that there was no breach of contract because the acceptance of Powell's appointment was never formally conveyed to him. The court noted that for a valid acceptance to constitute a contract, it must be communicated by an authorized person to the plaintiff. In the absence of such communication, a valid contract could not be formed. Thus, the court held that a contract was never established in this case.

Key point

A decision to accept is not enough. The acceptance must be communicated to the other party by an authorised person. News that reaches the other party through an unauthorised channel, as in Mr. Powell's case, does not create a contract.

Acceptance by Conduct

Acceptance by conduct occurs when a contract is formed through the actions or behavior of the parties rather than explicit communication. This type of acceptance, also known as acceptance by performance or behavior, does not require the offeree to communicate acceptance explicitly. Instead, the offeror infers (that is, concludes) acceptance from the offeree's actions.

Example

Zoya orders a product online from Farhan's store. Farhan delivers the product without Zoya receiving any explicit acceptance. Zoya's acceptance of the product constitutes acceptance by conduct. Her actions align with the terms of the offer, indicating acceptance.

For acceptance by conduct to be valid, two conditions must be satisfied:

  • the offeree's actions must clearly align with the offer's terms; and
  • the offer must not require explicit communication of acceptance.

An example of this can be seen in the case of Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Company, where the plaintiff's use of the smoke ball as directed was considered acceptance of the company's offer, forming a contract.

Example

Neha puts up a notice in her colony: “₹2,000 to anyone who finds and returns my lost dog.” Aadil reads the notice, finds the dog and returns it to Neha. Aadil never wrote or said “I accept”, but his act of performing the condition in the offer shows his acceptance. This works just like the use of the smoke ball in Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Company.

When Communication is Complete

Communication of acceptance is not complete at one single moment for both parties. The law looks at it separately from the side of the proposer and from the side of the acceptor:

  • As against the proposer (offeror): Communication is complete when the acceptance is put into transmission so that it is out of the offeree's control. This means that if the offeree sends the acceptance via post or other authorized means, the communication is considered complete once it is posted.
  • As against the acceptor (offeree): Communication is complete when the offeror becomes aware of the acceptance. This can happen if the acceptance is directly communicated by the offeree or through a messenger.
  • When transmitted through authorized means: If the acceptance is sent through a recognized and authorized means (such as postal service, telegraph, or fax), communication is considered complete when the message is transmitted.
Example

Hansa, who lives in Jaipur, makes an offer by letter to Aadil in Lucknow. Aadil posts his letter of acceptance on Monday, and it reaches Hansa on Thursday, when she reads it. As against Hansa (the proposer), communication of acceptance is complete on Monday, when Aadil posted the letter and it went out of his control. As against Aadil (the acceptor), communication is complete on Thursday, when Hansa becomes aware of the acceptance.

Acceptance by Post

Acceptance by post is a commonly used method in contract law, based on the principle that communication is complete when the acceptance is put in the course of transmission. This is popularly called the postal rule.

According to Section 4 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, if the offeree accepts the offer by post, the communication of acceptance is considered complete as soon as the acceptance is posted. This rule applies even if the acceptance is lost, delayed, or damaged in transit, provided the letter of acceptance is:

  • properly addressed;
  • properly stamped; and
  • actually posted.
Key point

Under the postal rule, the important moment is posting, not delivery. Once a properly addressed and stamped letter of acceptance is posted, communication of acceptance is complete as against the proposer.

Household Fire and Carriage Accident Insurance Company v Grant

Facts: In this case, Mr. Grant applied for shares in the Household Fire and Carriage Accident Insurance Company. The company accepted his offer by allotting shares to him and posting a letter of allotment to him. However, this letter of allotment was lost in the post and never reached Mr. Grant.

Arguments: The question was whether a binding contract had come into existence even though the acceptance (the letter of allotment) never reached Mr. Grant. (A counter-offer is a reply that changes the terms of the original offer; it is a new offer, not an acceptance.)

Judgement: The Court of Appeal (by a majority) held that the acceptance was complete as soon as the letter of allotment was posted, per the postal rule. The court determined that acceptance by post is effective as soon as it is posted, regardless of when it is received, or even if it is lost. The postal rule itself had been laid down earlier in Adams v Lindsell; this case is important because it applied the rule to a letter of acceptance that was lost in the post.

Case

Household Fire and Carriage Accident Insurance Company v Grant: Acceptance by post is effective as soon as it is posted, regardless of when it is received, and even if it is lost in the post.

Adams v Lindsell

Facts: In this case, Lindsell offered to sell a quantity of wool to Adams, with the offer made on September 2nd. Due to an addressing error, the offer reached Adams on September 5th, who accepted it on the same day by post. However, due to postal delays, Lindsell received the acceptance on September 9th, after selling the wool to someone else.

Decision: Adams sued for breach of contract, but Lindsell argued that no contract was formed since the acceptance arrived after the offer had been revoked (that is, withdrawn). The court ruled that the contract was formed when the acceptance was posted, not when it was received. This case reinforced the postal rule, establishing that acceptance is effective upon posting when using a reasonable means of communication like the postal service.

Case

Adams v Lindsell: The contract was formed on the day Adams posted his acceptance, not on the day Lindsell received it. A later sale of the wool to someone else could not undo a contract already formed by posting.

Place of Acceptance

The place of acceptance refers to the location where the offeree communicates acceptance to the offeror. This location determines the jurisdiction (which court can hear a dispute about the contract) and the applicable law for the contract.

  • Acceptance by post: The place of acceptance is where the acceptance is posted.
  • Telephone or telex: Acceptance is complete when the offeror receives the acceptance message, making the place of acceptance the location of the offeror.

The table below helps you revise the difference quickly:

Mode of acceptanceWhen acceptance is effectivePlace of acceptance
PostWhen the acceptance is postedWhere the acceptance is posted
Telephone or telexWhen the offeror receives the acceptance messageLocation of the offeror

Acceptance by Telephone or Telex

In cases of acceptance by telephone or telex, acceptance is not complete until the offeror receives the acceptance message. The place of contract formation is the location of the offeror. This differs from the postal rule, where acceptance is effective upon posting.

The reason is easy to understand: on a telephone call, the parties communicate almost instantly, so the law looks at the moment the offeror actually receives the acceptance, rather than the moment the acceptor speaks or sends it.

Case Example: Bhagwandas Goverdhandas Kedia v Girdharilal Parshottamdas and Co.

Facts: In this case, the plaintiffs at Ahmedabad made an offer over long-distance telephone to buy cotton seed cake from the defendants at Khamgaon, who accepted it on the telephone. When the plaintiffs sued at Ahmedabad for breach of contract, the defendants argued that the contract was made at Khamgaon, so the Ahmedabad court had no jurisdiction.

Decision: The Supreme Court (by majority) held that the postal rule does not apply to contracts made by telephone. Such a contract is complete only when the acceptance is communicated to the offeror, so it was made at Ahmedabad and the court there had jurisdiction.

Case

Bhagwan Das v Girdgari Lal: Acceptance given by telephone is valid. What matters is that the acceptance is communicated to the offeror; a written confirmation is not required unless it was asked for.

Acceptance Must Be Absolute and Unqualified

For acceptance to be valid, the offeree must accept all terms of the offer without modifications, conditions, or qualifications. Any attempt to change the offer terms constitutes a counter-offer, not acceptance, preventing a binding contract from forming.

This principle was illustrated in Hyde v. Wrench, where the plaintiff's counter-offer nullified the original offer, preventing a contract from forming when the plaintiff later tried to accept the original terms.

Example

Zoya offers to sell her scooter to Aadil for ₹40,000. Aadil replies, “I will buy it for ₹35,000.” This is not an acceptance but a counter-offer, and it puts an end to Zoya's original offer. Zoya refuses. The next day, Aadil says, “All right, I accept your offer of ₹40,000.” As in Hyde v. Wrench, Aadil cannot revive the original offer by accepting it now; there is no contract unless Zoya agrees afresh.

Acceptance Must Be in the Manner Prescribed by the Proposer

Under the Indian Contract Act, if the proposer specifies a particular manner for acceptance, it must be followed. This ensures clarity in how acceptance should be communicated. If the proposer specifies acceptance by email or fax, for example, then the offeree must use that method. However, if the acceptance is not made in the specified manner, the proposer may, within a reasonable time after the acceptance is communicated to him, insist that it be made in the prescribed manner and not otherwise; if he fails to do so, he accepts the acceptance (Section 7).

Example

Hansa offers to supply 100 chairs to Farhan's restaurant and writes, “Please send your acceptance only by email.” Farhan sends his acceptance by email to Hansa. Farhan has used the manner prescribed by the proposer, so his acceptance satisfies this requirement.

Conclusion

Acceptance is the step that turns a proposal into a promise under Section 2(b) of the Indian Contract Act 1872. To be valid, it must be given by the person to whom the proposal was made, in the prescribed manner, within the prescribed or a reasonable time, and it must be absolute and unqualified. It may be express (by words or writing) or implied (by conduct), but in every case it must be communicated.

For quick revision, remember these points:

  • Silence is not acceptance: Felthouse v Bindley.
  • Acceptance must be communicated by an authorised person: Mr. Powell's appointment as headmaster.
  • Acceptance can be by conduct: Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Company.
  • Postal rule — acceptance is effective on posting (Section 4): Household Fire and Carriage Accident Insurance Company v Grant and Adams v Lindsell.
  • Telephone or telex — acceptance is complete when the offeror receives it, at the offeror's location: Bhagwan Das v Girdgari Lal.
  • A counter-offer is not acceptance and ends the original offer: Hyde v. Wrench.

If you can explain each of these rules with its case and a simple example, you will be well prepared to answer any examination question on acceptance.

Practise Law of Contract I (General Principles) MCQs

115 questions. Every answer comes with an explanation and the legal provision behind it.

Practise now

Make this page yours

Sign in to save your reading progress and keep private notes and highlights. Free, and only you can see them.

Keep reading

Related notes

Law of Contract I (General Principles)

Proposal under Indian Contract Act

A proposal is when one person makes an offer to another person, intending to create a legally binding agreement. It shows their willingness to do or not do something, which becomes the basis of a contract.

18 min read

Law of Contract I (General Principles) Case compilation

Contract Law Important Case Laws

A couple went to England on leave. For health reasons, the wife was unable to accompany the husband again to Ceylon. The husband promised to pay 30 pounds per month to his wife as maintenance, but he failed to pay. The…

24 min read

Law of Contract I (General Principles) Complete notes

Law Of Contract One Shot

A contract is an agreement between two or more parties that the law can enforce. It happens when one person makes an offer, and the other person accepts it. For it to be a contract, there must be something valuable exch…

117 min read

Law of Contract I (General Principles)

Rules Regarding Minor’s Agreement

Understanding the Legal Framework and Implications Who is a Minor under Indian Contract Act, 1872? In India, anyone under the age of 18 is considered a minor. Even if a person is 17 years and 364 days old, they are stil…

12 min read

Law of Contract I (General Principles)

Free Consent under Indian Contract Act

Section 13 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, defines consent as "when two or more persons agree upon the same thing in the same sense." For two people willing to enter into an agreement, they must agree to the same thin…

9 min read

Judgments

Related case laws

Case law library

⚖️ Felthouse v. Bindley [1862] EWHC CP J35: Case Summary ⚖️ A landmark case on silence and acceptance in contract law 📌 Introduction This case established the principle that silence does not constitute acceptance in contract law and clarified that an offeror cannot impose an obligation on the offer…

Law of Contract I (General Principles)

Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co.

Law of Contract I (General Principles)

A landmark case on unilateral contracts and acceptance by performance

Law of Contract I (General Principles)

Doraswamy Iyer v. Arunachala Ayyar & Ors.

Madras High Court · 1935

This case examines consideration in contract law under Section 2(d) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 . It addresses whether a promise to contribute to a public cause without any binding obligation is enforceable.

Law of Contract I (General Principles) AIR 1936 Mad 135

Harvey v. Facey

Law of Contract I (General Principles)

Understanding the fine line between an offer and an invitation to treat

Law of Contract I (General Principles)

Watch

Related lectures