The Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (TPA) is a core subject in the LL.B. course and a regular topic in judiciary and other law examinations. Its sections are easier to understand, and much easier to remember, when you study them with the cases that applied them. This article brings together landmark cases on the main topics of the Act:
- the line between movable and immovable property;
- restraints on alienation under Section 10;
- transfers to a child in the mother's womb and to unborn persons (Section 13);
- vested and contingent interests;
- the doctrine of election;
- the ostensible owner under Section 41;
- the doctrine of lis pendens under Section 52;
- fraudulent transfers under Section 53;
- part performance under Section 53A;
- sale, marshalling, charges and mortgages; and
- actionable claims under Section 130.
Most cases below follow a simple Facts – Issue – Decision format, followed by a short explanation in plain words. Where a rule is abstract, a hypothetical example is added. The examples use imaginary people and are only meant to help you picture the rule. They are not real cases.
Case Summaries
1. Shantabai v. State of Bombay - Movable or Immovable
Why this case matters: Whether a right is over movable or immovable property is not just a theoretical question. As this case shows, the answer can decide whether an unregistered document gives the holder any enforceable right at all.
Facts: Shantabai's husband gave her rights, through an unregistered document, to cut bamboo and teak for 12.5 years. The government took over the forest under a law, and the Forest Officer stopped her from cutting.
Issue: Was Shantabai's right over movable or immovable property?
Decision: The court held that Shantabai's right was over immovable property, because it involved the long-term growth and nurturing of the trees. Since the document was not registered, her right could not be enforced.
In simple words: Shantabai was not buying trees that were ready to be cut and carried away at once. Her right ran for more than twelve years, during which the trees would keep growing from the soil. Because the right was tied to the land in this way, the court treated it as a right over immovable property. Her document was unregistered, so it failed.
A long-term right that depends on the trees continuing to grow and draw nourishment from the land was treated as a right over immovable property. In Shantabai's case, the lack of registration meant the right could not be enforced.
2. Ananda Behera vs. State of Odisha - Movable or Immovable
Facts: Ananda Behera had the right to fish in a specific pond or water body. The question in the case was whether his fishing rights were movable or immovable property.
Issue: Are fishing rights movable property (things that can be separated and moved) or immovable property (things connected to the land)?
Decision: The court decided that fishing rights are immovable property. This is because these rights come from the land and cannot be separated from it. The court said that a benefit arising out of land, such as a profit-a-prendre, is immovable property under the Transfer of Property Act read with the General Clauses Act.
In simple words: A fish that has already been caught can be carried away, so it is movable. But the right to go on catching fish in a particular water body comes from that land and water itself. The right cannot exist apart from the place, so the court treated it as immovable property.
Prince owns a village pond in Odisha. He grants Farhan the right to catch fish in that pond for the next five years. Following the reasoning in Ananda Behera, Farhan's right is a benefit arising from the land (the pond) and is treated as immovable property, even though each fish he catches becomes movable once it is taken out.
3. State of Orissa vs. Titaghur Paper Mills Co. - Movable or Immovable
Facts: The case was about whether the right to cut and take bamboo from a forest should be taxed. The government said bamboo was movable property, so it could be taxed like goods.
Issue: Titaghur Paper Mills argued that the bamboo licence was not a contract to buy or sell goods, but a lease of land. They said it gave them the right to benefit from the land, called a "profit-a-prendre".
Meaning of profit-a-prendre: This French expression means a right to take something (a "profit") from another person's land, such as timber, bamboo, crops or fish. The person holding the right does not own the land, but has the right to enter it and take something from it.
Decision: The court agreed with Titaghur Paper Mills. It decided that the licence to cut bamboo was an interest in immovable property (like a lease), not a sale of goods, so it could not be taxed as a sale.
In simple words: The government saw the deal as a sale of bamboo (goods). The company saw it as a right connected with the land itself. As stated here, the court accepted the company's view: the licence was an interest in immovable property, so sales tax on goods could not be charged on it.
4. Mohammad Raza v. Abbas Bandi Bibi - Alienation (Section 10)
Meaning of alienation: In property law, to "alienate" property simply means to transfer it to someone else, for example by sale, gift or mortgage. A "restraint on alienation" is a condition that stops or limits the owner from transferring the property.
Facts: A family made an agreement saying that the property each person received could not be sold to anyone outside the family. They decided that the property would pass down to their legal heirs (children, grandchildren, and so on) from generation to generation.
Issue: Was this agreement, which restricted selling the property to outsiders, legally valid?
Decision: The court said that, according to Section 10 of the Transfer of Property Act, a partial restriction on selling property is allowed. So, as long as the agreement does not completely stop the person from transferring the property, it is valid and enforceable.
In simple words: The family members could still sell their shares, but only within the family. Because they were not totally barred from transferring, the restriction was only partial, and the court upheld it.
5. Laxmannamma vs. State of Karnataka - Alienation (Section 10)
Key Facts: The dispute arose when a transfer deed included a condition restricting the owner from transferring the property outside the family. The intention was to keep the property within the family for future generations.
Decision: The court examined Section 10 of the Transfer of Property Act. It clarified that an absolute restriction on transferring property is generally considered void unless it is a specific, reasonable limitation. The court ruled that partial restrictions, which allow transfers within a limited context such as among family members, are valid.
Absolute and partial restraint compared:
| Type of restriction | What it does | Position stated in these cases |
|---|---|---|
| Absolute restraint | Completely stops the owner from transferring the property | Generally void under Section 10 |
| Partial restraint | Allows transfer, but only in a limited way (for example, only within the family) | Valid |
Zoya gifts a flat in Bengaluru to her niece Neha with a condition that Neha may never transfer it to anyone at all. This is a complete bar, so it is an absolute restraint. If, instead, the condition says that Neha may sell the flat but only to members of the family, it is a partial restraint of the kind that was upheld in Mohammad Raza and Laxmannamma.
6. Tagore vs. Tagore - Mother Womb
Decision: The court said that an unborn child in the mother's womb is considered a person for property transfers. This means transfers can be made to children who are yet to be born, as long as they are in the womb.
In simple words: A transfer needs someone to receive the property. A child already conceived, though not yet born, is treated as being in existence for this purpose. So a gift can be made in favour of such a child.
Hansa is expecting a baby. Her father, Aadil, executes a gift deed of a plot of land in favour of the child in Hansa's womb. Under the rule in Tagore v. Tagore, the child is treated as a person for this transfer, even though the baby has not yet been born.
7. Girjesh Dutt v. Data Din - Unborn Child
Facts:
- A woman (A) gifted her property to her nephew's daughter (B) for her lifetime.
- After B's life, the property was to go to B's male children, if she had any.
- If B had no male children, the property would go to B's daughter, but B's daughter was not allowed to sell or transfer it.
- If B had no children at all, the property would go to A's nephew.
- B died without any children.
Judgment:
- The court said that the gift to B for her lifetime was valid, because B was alive when the transfer was made.
- However, the gift to B's daughter was invalid under Section 13 of the Transfer of Property Act (TPA), because the daughter was given only limited rights, not full ownership.
- Since the transfer to B's daughter was not valid, any further transfer that depended on it (such as the gift to A's nephew) also failed.
In simple terms, the court allowed the gift to B because she was alive, but the gift to B's future children did not work because it did not give them full rights.
Understanding the chain: Think of the gift as a chain with several links.
- Link 1 – B for life: valid, because B was a living person.
- Link 2 – B's unborn daughter with a restricted interest: invalid under Section 13, because the unborn daughter was not given the whole interest; she was barred from selling or transferring it.
- Link 3 – A's nephew: this gift depended on the failed link, so it fell along with it.
When property is given to a person who is not yet born, after an earlier interest (such as a life interest), the gift to the unborn person must be of full rights. A cut-down interest, like the restricted interest given to B's daughter, fails under Section 13. A later gift that depends on that failed gift also fails.
8. Lachman v. Baldeo - Vested Interest
Meaning of vested interest: An interest is "vested" when the person already has a legal right to the property, even if the actual enjoyment (possession and use) is postponed to a later date.
Facts: A person made a gift of property to someone else (the transferee), but said that the transferee would get possession of the property only after the transferor (the person giving the gift) died.
Judgment: The court said that the transferee still has a vested interest (a legal right to the property), even though he cannot enjoy or use the property until the transferor dies.
Conclusion: The person receiving the gift has the right to the property from the moment the gift is made, but will be able to take possession and use it only after the giver passes away.
Renu executes a gift deed of her farmland in favour of her nephew Prince, with a clause that Prince will take possession only after Renu's death. Following Lachman v. Baldeo, Prince has a vested interest from the date of the gift. Only the possession and enjoyment are postponed until Renu's death.
9. Kokilambal v. N Raman - Contingent Interest
Meaning of contingent interest: A contingent interest is one that depends on some uncertain event happening. It is the opposite of a vested interest, which is already a present right. This case also turned on whether the rights given to B were heritable, meaning whether they could pass to B's heirs after B's death.
Facts:
- A transferred an estate to B. Both A and B were to enjoy the estate together during A's lifetime.
- B was responsible for collecting rent, making repairs and paying taxes. After these expenses, the remaining money was to be shared equally between A and B.
- A and B could transfer the estate jointly, but B died before any further transfer.
- After B's death, A cancelled the transfer and gave the estate to D.
- B's legal heirs filed a case claiming that B had a vested interest in the estate, and that this interest should pass to B's beneficiaries.
Judgment:
- The Supreme Court decided that A still had some rights in the estate and had not completely transferred the estate to B.
- The court ruled that B's rights in the estate were not heritable (they did not pass to B's heirs).
- Therefore, B's heirs had no claim to the estate, and the court dismissed their case.
Conclusion:
- In this case, the entitlements made in favour of B were not permanent or heritable.
- A still had some control over the property, so B's beneficiaries had no rights after B's death.
- The decision is based on the principles of justice, equity and good conscience that guide the Transfer of Property Act.
In simple words: B's heirs could claim only what B had. Because A had kept rights in the estate and B's rights ended with B, there was nothing left for B's heirs to inherit.
10. Valliammai v. Nagappa (1967) - Doctrine of Election
Meaning of election: "Election" means choosing. The doctrine of election is based on fairness: a person who takes a benefit under a transaction cannot, at the same time, reject the part of the same transaction that goes against him. He must choose either to accept the transaction as a whole or to reject it.
Decision: The Supreme Court held that the question of election arises only when the transferee takes the benefit directly under the transaction.
In simple words: A person is put to a choice only if the benefit he receives comes to him directly from the very transaction that also affects his own property. If the benefit does not come to him directly under that transaction, the question of election does not arise.
By one deed, Farhan gives his own house to Aadil and, in the same deed, also purports to give Aadil's shop to Zoya. Aadil takes a benefit (the house) directly under the deed, so he must elect: either accept the house and let the shop go to Zoya, or keep his shop and give up the benefit under the deed.
11. Ramcoomar Koondoo v. John and Maria McQueen - Ostensible Owner (Section 41)
Meaning of ostensible owner: An "ostensible" owner is a person who appears to be the owner of a property, with the consent of the real owner, but is not the real owner. A benamidar is a person in whose name property is held, while someone else has actually paid for it and is the real owner.
Facts:
- Alexander paid for a property but registered it in the name of his lover, Bunnoo Bebee, making her the benamidar (holding the property on his behalf).
- Bunnoo Bebee sold the property to Ramdhan while Alexander was still alive.
- After Alexander's death, his daughter Maria inherited the property through his will. But by then the property had already been sold to Ramcoomar, who believed he was the rightful owner.
Issue: Maria sued Ramcoomar to get the property back, claiming that it belonged to her father.
Decision: The court ruled that Maria could not take back the property. The sale was considered valid because Alexander, the real owner, had allowed Bunnoo Bebee to act as the owner, and Ramcoomar bought it in good faith, without knowing the real situation.
Conclusion: The case, decided by the Privy Council before the Transfer of Property Act was enacted, laid down the principle later embodied in Section 41: if a person appears to be the owner with the real owner's consent and the buyer acts in good faith, the transfer cannot be avoided, even if the seller was not the true owner.
Elements to remember: From this case, the protection for the buyer rests on the following points:
- The seller appeared to be the owner (ostensible owner).
- The real owner had allowed the seller to act as the owner.
- The buyer purchased in good faith, without knowing the true position.
A real owner who lets another person appear to the world as the owner cannot later undo a sale made by that person to a buyer who acted in good faith.
12. Sanjay Verma v. Manik Roy - Doctrine of Lis Pendens
Meaning of lis pendens: This Latin phrase means "a pending suit" or "pending litigation". The doctrine, contained in Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act, deals with what happens when property that is the subject of a court case is transferred while the case is still going on.
Facts: In this case, a property was being disputed in court. One of the parties tried to transfer the property during the case.
Issue: Did transferring the property while the case was still going on affect the rights of the other party?
Judgment: The court said that the mere fact that a case is ongoing does not mean a party cannot deal with the property. However, the court made it clear that any transfer made during a pending case would not change the final rights of the other party as decided by the court. So, the transfer is valid but must follow whatever the court finally decides.
In simple words: A party may sell or otherwise deal with the property during the case, but the buyer steps into that party's shoes and is bound by the final judgment. The transfer cannot be used to defeat the other side's rights.
13. Kamalammal v. Senthil - Doctrine Of Lis Pendens
Facts: In this case, Kamalammal owned a piece of land, and a court case was going on regarding the ownership of this land. While the case was still in progress, Kamalammal sold the land to Senthil.
Issue: Could Senthil claim ownership of the land even though it was sold during a court case about the same land?
Judgment: The court applied Section 52 (Doctrine of Lis Pendens) and ruled that the sale made during the court case was not valid against the final court decision. The court decided that Senthil had to accept the court's ruling, and his ownership depended on the outcome of the case.
Hansa and Renu are fighting a civil suit over who owns a plot in Madurai. While the suit is pending, Hansa sells the plot to Prince. If the court finally decides that Renu is the owner, Prince cannot keep the plot against Renu merely because he bought it from Hansa. Like Senthil, his rights depend on the result of the case.
Read the two lis pendens cases together: a transfer made while the case is pending is not wiped out completely, but it is always subject to the final decision of the court (Section 52).
14. Abdul Shukoor vs. Arji Papa Rao and Ors. - Fraudulent Transfer
Judgment: In this case, the court held that if a debtor delays the creditors by making transfers that avoid paying them, Section 53 can be applied to make those transfers invalid.
Summary: Section 53 protects creditors from being cheated by owners who try to hide or transfer their property to avoid paying debts. If the owner acts dishonestly, creditors can go to court and cancel the transfer. But if the buyer did everything in good faith, the buyer's rights are protected.
Points to remember:
- Who is protected: creditors of the person transferring the property.
- What is attacked: transfers made to delay creditors or avoid paying them.
- Remedy: creditors can go to court to have such a transfer cancelled.
- Exception: a buyer who acted in good faith is protected.
Aadil owes Farhan a large sum of money. When Farhan demands payment, Aadil quickly transfers his only house to his cousin so that nothing is left for Farhan to recover from. Farhan, as a creditor, can approach the court under Section 53 to have this transfer cancelled. If, however, the house had been sold to a buyer who acted in good faith, that buyer's rights would be protected.
15. Santaram Dewangan v. Shivprasad - Part Performance
Meaning of part performance: "Part performance" refers to a situation where the parties have agreed to transfer property and the buyer has already acted on the agreement (for example, by taking possession), even though the formal transfer, such as a registered sale deed, has not been completed. Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act protects such a transferee.
Facts: A dispute arose when the transferee claimed possession of the property based on an agreement, even though the sale deed was not registered.
Held: The Supreme Court applied Section 53A and protected the possession of the transferee, emphasising that a delay in the legal paperwork should not harm someone who acted in good faith.
Legal Principle: The doctrine of part performance provides protection to transferees who fulfil their obligations, even if the final sale deed is not ready.
16. Ameer Minhaj v. Dierdre Elizabeth - Part Performance
Facts: Ameer Minhaj had a written agreement to purchase a property, and he took possession of it. Later, a dispute arose over the final registration of the sale deed.
Held: The Supreme Court (2018) held that, under Section 17(1A) read with Section 49 of the Registration Act, an agreement to sell executed after 24 September 2001 must be registered if it is to be relied on under Section 53A; an unregistered agreement can be received only as evidence of the contract in a suit for specific performance and has no effect for the purposes of Section 53A.
Legal Principle: Section 53A prevents the transferor from taking back the property if the transferee has followed through on his side of the deal.
17. Miaan Pir Baksh v. Saddar Mohammad - Part Performance
Facts: This case, decided by the Privy Council, involved a situation where the transferee had a written agreement and had taken steps to fulfil his obligations.
Held: The Privy Council held that the English doctrine of part performance was not available in India as a defence to an action for ejectment, and that its view related to the law before Section 53A was inserted, after the suit was brought; the transferee's possession was therefore not protected.
Part performance at a glance: From the three cases above, the transferee's protection is linked to these features:
- There is a written agreement to transfer the property, which (since 24 September 2001) must also be registered.
- The transferee has taken possession (or has otherwise acted on the agreement).
- The transferee has fulfilled, or taken steps to fulfil, his part of the deal in good faith.
- The final registered sale deed is not yet in place.
Neha signs a written agreement to buy a shop from Zoya in Raipur, pays the price and is put in possession. Before the sale deed is registered, Zoya changes her mind and tries to evict Neha. Applying the principle in these cases, Section 53A protects Neha's possession, provided her written agreement is registered (required since 24 September 2001 by Section 17(1A) of the Registration Act) and she has done her part.
18. Sujan Singh v. Lal Saheb - Sale
Facts: The plaintiff filed a case to cancel a sale deed, claiming that although the sale deed mentioned payment, the money was never actually paid. The defendant argued that, if the court found that the payment had not been made, the plaintiff should still be required to accept the payment now, instead of the sale deed being cancelled.
Issue: Should the court allow the defendant's request that the plaintiff accept the payment now and that the sale deed not be cancelled?
Held: The court rejected the defendant's request. It ruled that the sale deed was void due to non-payment, and that it would be unfair to force the plaintiff to accept payment at that stage.
In simple words: The buyer could not escape the consequences of not paying by offering the money only after the seller had gone to court. The court would not compel the seller to take the money so late in the day.
19. Md Rafeeq v. Bank of Baroda - Marshalling Law
Meaning of marshalling: "Marshalling" means arranging claims in a fair order. In simple terms, where a creditor has security over more than one property, the rule of marshalling can allow a later purchaser or mortgagee of one property to ask that the debt be recovered first from the other properties, so that his property is relieved of the burden as far as possible.
Facts: Muhammed Rafeeq bought a property from a borrower who had taken a loan from the bank. The bank had created a security interest over that property.
Issue: Muhammed Rafeeq tried to use the Rule of Marshalling to clear the property of debts.
Decision: The court ruled that since the SARFAESI Act, 2002 (an Act about banks' recovery of debts) applied in this case, the Rule of Marshalling could not be used.
This case shows that the general rule of marshalling under property law did not help the purchaser where the bank's recovery was governed by the SARFAESI Act, 2002. Anyone buying property that is already offered as security to a bank should keep this in mind.
20. JK (Bombay) Private Ltd vs. New Kaiser-I-Hind Spinning and Weaving Co Ltd. - Charges
Decision: In this case, the Supreme Court said that a charge on a property means that the property is used as security for payment, but without transferring any ownership or interest in the property.
On the other hand, a mortgage transfers an interest in the property (Section 58 defines a mortgage as the transfer of an interest in specific immovable property). The court also explained that no special wording is required to create a charge, but there must be a clear intention to use the property as security for payment at the present time.
Charge and mortgage compared:
| Point | Charge | Mortgage |
|---|---|---|
| Property used as security for payment? | Yes | Yes |
| Transfer of ownership or interest? | No | Yes (as stated by the court in this case) |
| Special words needed to create it? | No, but there must be a clear present intention to make the property security for payment | — |
Prince borrows money from Hansa and signs a document stating that his godown in Mumbai will stand as security for repayment from today. Even though the document does not use any technical word like "charge", the clear present intention to make the godown security for payment is enough to create a charge. Prince does not transfer any ownership or interest in the godown to Hansa.
21. Mathai Mathai v. Joseph Mary (2014) - Mortgage
Facts: In this case, a mortgage deed was executed in favour of a 15-year-old minor (the mortgagee) as security for a dowry amount of 7,000 Chakram. The court found that this mortgage was invalid because a minor cannot legally enter into a mortgage contract.
Court's Decision: The court said that a mortgage is like a contract, and since a minor does not have the legal capacity to make such agreements, the mortgage was void (invalid). A minor needs to be represented by a legal guardian or someone appointed by the court to enter into such agreements.
In simple words: Since a mortgage is treated like a contract, the person making it must be legally capable of contracting. A 15-year-old is not, so the court held that a mortgage taken in the minor's name, without a natural guardian or court-appointed guardian, was void, even though the minor was the mortgagee and not the mortgagor. If a minor's property is to be dealt with, it must be done through a legal guardian or a person appointed by the court.
22. Doriaswami Mudaliar v. D. Aiyangar - Actionable Claim
Meaning of actionable claim: An actionable claim is a claim to money or a benefit which a person can enforce by going to court (by "action"), but which he does not presently hold in his hands and which is not secured by property, for example an unsecured debt owed to him.
Decision: In this case, the Madras High Court said that even though Section 130 does not prescribe the exact words to be used for a transfer, the intention to transfer must be clear. The document should make it easy to understand that the transfer is happening, even if specific words are not used.
Summary: Actionable claims are claims to money or benefits that are not secured by property. They can be transferred through a written document, and the new owner gets all the rights to claim the debt or benefit.
Farhan has lent ₹50,000 to Aadil without any security. Farhan signs a written document in favour of Renu, clearly stating that Renu is now entitled to recover this debt from Aadil. The document does not use any fixed legal formula, but the intention to transfer is clear. Renu now holds the rights to claim the debt.
Conclusion
These cases show how the short sections of the Transfer of Property Act work in real disputes. The movable/immovable cases (Shantabai, Ananda Behera and Titaghur Paper Mills) show that rights tied to the land, such as long-term rights to cut trees or to fish, can be immovable property. The Section 10 cases show that partial restraints, like keeping property within the family, are treated differently from absolute ones. Tagore v. Tagore, Girjesh Dutt and Lachman explain transfers to a child in the womb, transfers to unborn persons and vested interests. The cases on Sections 41, 52, 53 and 53A protect buyers in good faith, parties to pending litigation, creditors and transferees in possession. The last group of cases explains sale, marshalling, charges, mortgages and actionable claims.
For examinations, remember each case by linking it to its topic and the one principle it stands for. The table below can be used for quick revision.
| Case | Topic | Principle in one line |
|---|---|---|
| Shantabai v. State of Bombay | Movable or immovable | Long-term right involving growth of trees was over immovable property; unregistered document could not be enforced |
| Ananda Behera vs. State of Odisha | Movable or immovable | Fishing rights arise from the land and are immovable property |
| State of Orissa vs. Titaghur Paper Mills Co. | Movable or immovable | Licence to cut bamboo treated as an interest in immovable property, not a sale of goods |
| Mohammad Raza v. Abbas Bandi Bibi | Section 10 | Partial restriction on sale (only outside the family) is valid |
| Laxmannamma vs. State of Karnataka | Section 10 | Absolute restraint generally void; partial restraint within family valid |
| Tagore vs. Tagore | Child in womb | Child in the mother's womb is a person for property transfers |
| Girjesh Dutt v. Data Din | Unborn child (Section 13) | Gift of limited rights to an unborn person fails; dependent gift also fails |
| Lachman v. Baldeo | Vested interest | Right vests at once though possession is postponed till the giver's death |
| Kokilambal v. N Raman | Contingent interest | B's rights were not heritable; B's heirs had no claim |
| Valliammai v. Nagappa (1967) | Election | Election arises only when the benefit is taken directly under the transaction |
| Ramcoomar Koondoo v. John and Maria McQueen | Section 41 | Sale by ostensible owner to buyer in good faith is valid |
| Sanjay Verma v. Manik Roy | Section 52 | Transfer during a pending case is subject to the final decision |
| Kamalammal v. Senthil | Section 52 | Buyer during litigation is bound by the outcome of the case |
| Abdul Shukoor vs. Arji Papa Rao and Ors. | Section 53 | Transfers made to delay or avoid creditors can be set aside; good-faith buyer protected |
| Santaram Dewangan v. Shivprasad | Section 53A | Possession of transferee acting in good faith protected despite unregistered deed |
| Ameer Minhaj v. Dierdre Elizabeth | Section 53A | Unregistered agreement to sell (made after 2001) has no effect for Section 53A; admissible only as evidence in a specific performance suit |
| Miaan Pir Baksh v. Saddar Mohammad | Section 53A | Pre-Section 53A case: English doctrine of part performance not available as a defence; transferee's possession not protected |
| Sujan Singh v. Lal Saheb | Sale | Buyer who did not pay cannot force the seller to accept payment late |
| Md Rafeeq v. Bank of Baroda | Marshalling | Rule of marshalling not available where SARFAESI Act, 2002 applied |
| JK (Bombay) Private Ltd vs. New Kaiser-I-Hind Spinning and Weaving Co Ltd. | Charges | Charge makes property security without transferring interest; no special words needed |
| Mathai Mathai v. Joseph Mary (2014) | Mortgage | Mortgage in favour of a minor mortgagee not represented by a guardian is void |
| Doriaswami Mudaliar v. D. Aiyangar | Actionable claim (Section 130) | No set words needed, but intention to transfer must be clear |
Read each case alongside the bare text of the relevant section, and use the examples above to test whether you can apply the rule to a new set of facts. That habit will help you both in your semester examinations and in competitive law examinations.