Quick answer
Yes, a co-owner who is legally competent may sell his share, and under Section 44 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 the buyer generally steps into his shoes, including the right to joint possession and the right to sue for partition. But where the property is a dwelling house belonging to an undivided family and the buyer is not a member of that family, the second paragraph of Section 44 gives the stranger no right to joint possession or common enjoyment of the house. His remedy is a suit for partition, in which family members may buy him out under Section 4 of the Partition Act, 1893.
The law: Section 44
First paragraph: where one of two or more co-owners of immovable property, legally competent in that behalf, transfers his share or any interest in it, the transferee acquires that share or interest, and so far as necessary to give effect to the transfer, the transferor's right to joint possession or common or part enjoyment of the property and to enforce a partition, subject to the conditions and liabilities affecting the share on the date of the transfer.
Second paragraph: where the transferee of a share of a dwelling house belonging to an undivided family is not a member of the family, nothing in the section entitles him to joint possession or other common or part enjoyment of the house.
Section 4, Partition Act, 1893: where such an outsider sues for partition, and a member of the family who is a shareholder undertakes to buy his share, the court values the share and directs its sale to that shareholder.
Ordinary co-owned property and a family dwelling house compared
| Point | Ordinary co-owned immovable property | Dwelling house of an undivided family, sold to a stranger |
|---|---|---|
| Buyer gets the share | Yes | Yes |
| Joint possession or common enjoyment | Yes, as the transferor had it | No (Section 44, second paragraph) |
| Right to sue for partition | Yes | Yes, but family shareholders may buy out his share under Section 4, Partition Act |
| Purpose | Free transfer of property rights | Protecting the privacy of the family home from intrusion by outsiders |
Dorab Cawasji Warden v. Coomi Sorab Warden, Supreme Court of India, 13 February 1990 ((1990) 2 SCC 117; AIR 1990 SC 867). Two brothers each held an undivided half share in a bungalow. After one brother died, his widow and sons sold their half share to strangers, who took possession. The Supreme Court restored the trial court's interim mandatory injunction against the strangers. It held that the second paragraph of Section 44 and Section 4 of the Partition Act are complementary, so "undivided family" and "dwelling house" carry the same meaning in both. Approving earlier High Court rulings, the Court accepted that "undivided family" is not limited to a Hindu joint family; the provision is of general application, and what matters is that the family owns the house and has not divided it by metes and bounds (actual physical division).
Essential points
- The transferor must be a co-owner legally competent to transfer.
- The buyer takes the share subject to the conditions and liabilities affecting it on the date of transfer.
- The protection applies only to a dwelling house belonging to an undivided family, and only against a buyer who is not a member of that family.
- The stranger does not lose the share; he only cannot force his way into the house. He can sue for partition.
Example
Brothers Farhan and Aadil jointly own their undivided family house, where both families live. Aadil sells his half share to Renu, who is not a family member. Renu becomes the owner of that share, but she cannot move into the house or demand a bedroom under Section 44. She may file a suit for partition, and if Farhan undertakes to buy her share, the court will value it and direct its sale to him under Section 4 of the Partition Act.
For an overview of transfers under the Act, see Concept of Transfer of Property.
Exam point
A stranger who buys a share in an undivided family's dwelling house gets the share and the right to sue for partition, but no right to joint possession of the house (Section 44, second paragraph; Dorab Cawasji Warden, 1990).