Who counts as a minor in Indian law, and what can a minor legally do? A minor cannot enter into a valid contract, yet a minor can receive property. A very young child cannot be punished for a crime, while an older child may or may not be, depending on how mature the child is. This article explains the legal status of minors under the Indian Contract Act, 1872, the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, the Indian Succession Act, 1925 and the Indian Penal Code (now replaced by the B.N.S.). These topics are often asked about in LL.B. examinations and judiciary papers.
Who Is a Minor?
A minor is a person who has not yet reached the legal age of adulthood. Because of this, a minor does not have the full legal rights and capacities of an adult.
In India, a person is generally treated as a minor until the age of 18. The law sees minors as still growing physically and mentally. For this reason, they do not have the legal capacity to do certain things, for example:
- entering into contracts; and
- voting.
Once a person turns 18, he or she becomes an adult and can exercise the same legal rights and carry the same legal responsibilities as other adults.
Zoya is 17 years old. She cannot vote and cannot make a valid contract. On her 18th birthday she becomes an adult in law and gains these legal capacities.
However, maturity does not depend on age alone. Some minors may understand things better and behave more maturely than some adults. Even so, the law provides that all minors are entitled to equal treatment, without discrimination based on sex, race, caste, disability or religion. The legal status of minors is governed by different provisions spread across Indian law, which are discussed below.
Legal Status of Minors According to Indian Laws
Indian Contract Act, 1872
Under the Indian Contract Act, 1872, a person below 18 years of age is a minor and is not legally competent to enter into a contract.
According to Section 2 of the Act, the parties to a contract must be competent. This means they must not be:
- minors;
- persons of unsound mind; or
- persons otherwise disqualified by law.
Section 3 of the Indian Majority Act, 1875 further makes it clear that a minor is a person who has not completed 18 years of age. So the Contract Act tells us that a minor cannot contract, and the Indian Majority Act tells us who a minor is.
Mohri Bibi v. Damodardas Ghosh: In this landmark case, the court held that any agreement made by a minor is void ab initio. As a result, courts cannot order specific performance of contracts involving minors.
Two terms used here need explanation:
- Void ab initio is a Latin phrase meaning “void from the beginning”. Such an agreement is treated as if it never had any legal effect at all.
- Specific performance is a remedy in which a court orders a party to actually do what was promised in the contract, instead of only paying compensation.
Aadil, aged 16, signs an agreement to sell his bicycle to Farhan. Because Aadil is a minor, the agreement is void from the start. Farhan cannot go to court and ask for an order forcing Aadil to hand over the bicycle.
Transfer of Property Act, 1882
Minors are not competent to contract, and this position applies under the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 as well. However, minors are permitted to accept gifts of immovable property without the intervention of a guardian. In other words, a minor can receive property even though the minor cannot make a contract.
Hansa gifts a small plot of land to her 12-year-old niece, Renu. Although Renu cannot enter into a contract, she can accept this gift of immovable property.
According to Section 13 of the Act, property can be transferred to an unborn child. In such cases:
- a life interest is created, that is, a right to use and enjoy the property for the lifetime of the person holding it;
- the life holder enjoys the property on behalf of the unborn child; and
- the life holder cannot transfer the property.
A minor can also acquire immovable property through his or her own funds.
Indian Succession Act, 1925
Section 144 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 allows a prior interest in property to be created for an unborn child. The key points are:
- the interest in the property becomes vested (that is, it becomes a fixed and settled right) only if the child is born alive;
- until then, the child’s interest is contingent, meaning it depends on a future event, namely the child’s birth; and
- in this way, the provision protects the property rights of unborn children.
Prince creates an interest in his property for the child his daughter Neha is expecting. The child’s interest becomes vested only when the child is born alive. Until the birth, the interest remains contingent.
Position and Legal Status of Minors According to the Indian Penal Code
The Indian Penal Code has now been replaced by the B.N.S. The same rules on child offenders now appear in Sections 20 and 21 of the B.N.S. The IPC section numbers are kept below because the older judgments and the established discussion refer to them.
Complete immunity: children below 7 years (Section 82 IPC)
Under Section 82 of the Indian Penal Code, a child under the age of 7 has complete immunity from criminal liability. A child of this age cannot be held guilty of any offence because the child lacks the capacity to tell right from wrong.
The law assumes that a child below 7 does not have the understanding needed to grasp the nature and consequences of his or her actions. Therefore, there is no mens rea in such cases. Mens rea is a Latin term meaning “guilty mind”, that is, criminal intent or knowledge. Without it, criminal liability cannot arise.
Six-year-old Farhan picks up a toy from a shop and walks out without paying. Because he is under 7, he cannot be held guilty of any offence, however clear the facts may be.
Partial immunity: children above 7 and below 12 years (Section 83 IPC)
Section 83 of the Indian Penal Code gives partial immunity to children above 7 years but below 12 years. A child in this age group may be capable of understanding the nature and consequences of his or her actions, but this depends on the individual child’s level of maturity.
Maturity of Understanding
For children between 7 and 12 years, liability depends on their level of maturity and understanding. Consider two situations:
- If a 10-year-old child lacks the ability to understand the consequences of his actions, he may be absolved (freed) from liability.
- If a 9-year-old child shows sufficient maturity and understanding, he can be held liable.
So age alone does not decide the matter for this group. A younger child may be liable while an older child may not be. The child’s maturity and understanding are assessed on the basis of the circumstances surrounding the crime, and this varies from case to case.
Aadil, aged 11, carefully hides a classmate’s watch, lies when questioned and later tries to sell it. Such conduct may show that he understood what he was doing and its consequences. On the other hand, if 10-year-old Prince takes a watch simply because it looks shiny, with no sign that he understands it is wrong, he may be absolved.
Under the Indian Penal Code, when dealing with children in this age range, it must be proven that the child did not possess sufficient maturity or understanding to grasp the nature and consequences of the offence committed.
Below 7 years: complete immunity (Section 82 IPC). Above 7 and below 12 years: partial immunity, depending on maturity of understanding (Section 83 IPC).
Krishna Bhagwan v. State of Bihar: The court held that if a child accused of a crime reaches the age of 7 during the trial, or by the time the verdict is given, the child can be convicted if found to understand the nature and consequences of his or her actions.
Marsh v. Loader: A child was caught stealing a piece of wood from the defendant’s property. The child was not held liable and was discharged because he was under 7 years old.
Conclusion
In India, a minor is generally anyone under the age of 18. The law assumes that people below this age may not fully understand the nature and consequences of their actions because they lack maturity. As a result, minors are not given certain legal rights, such as the right to vote.
However, maturity does not depend on age alone. Some minors show sufficient understanding and maturity, while some adults do not. The law reflects this in different ways:
- under the Indian Contract Act, 1872, a minor’s agreement is void from the beginning;
- under the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, a minor can still accept gifts of immovable property and acquire property with his or her own funds, and Section 13 deals with transfers to unborn children;
- under the Indian Succession Act, 1925, Section 144 protects interests created for unborn children; and
- under criminal law, children below 7 have complete immunity, while children between 7 and 12 have partial immunity depending on their maturity.
Despite differences in maturity and development, every child is entitled to fundamental rights, such as the right to life under Article 21 of the Indian Constitution. Every child must be provided with a safe environment, good nutrition, healthcare and education. All children are entitled to equal treatment, without discrimination based on sex, race, caste, disability or religion.