Skip to content
The Law Easy
Case law Landmark judgment Law of Contract I (General Principles)

Jenning v. Rundall & Leslie (R) Ltd. v. Sheill – Case Summary

These cases reaffirm the protection granted to minors in contract law , emphasizing that minors cannot be held liable for breach of contract and that a contractual claim cannot be converted into a tort claim to impose liability on minors.

Published Updated 39,423 views

Case at a glance

Court
King’s Bench
Year
1799
Subject
Law of Contract I (General Principles)
Cover: Jenning v. Rundall & Leslie (R) Ltd. v. Sheill
On this page

Facts

Jenning v. Rundall (1799): A minor hired a mare for a short ride but overrode it and injured it. The plaintiff first sued in contract, but the contract was unenforceable because the minor lacked capacity. The plaintiff then tried to sue in tort for the damage caused to the mare.

Leslie (R) Ltd. v. Sheill (1914): A minor fraudulently misrepresented his age to obtain a loan. Since contracts with minors are void, the lender could not sue in contract. The lender then sued the minor in tort for deceit to recover the money.

Issues

1. Can a plaintiff who cannot sue a minor in contract reframe the same claim as a tort claim to make the minor liable?

2. Can a minor who lied about his age to obtain a loan be sued in tort for deceit when the effect would be to enforce the loan contract indirectly?

3. What, if anything, can the other party recover from the minor?

Arguments

In Jenning v. Rundall, the plaintiff converted a contract claim into a tort claim and sued for the damage done to the mare.

In Leslie (R) Ltd. v. Sheill, the lender sued in tort for deceit to recover the money lent, because the minor had obtained the loan by lying about his age.

Judgment

Jenning v. Rundall: The court held that a claim founded on a contract cannot be turned into a tort claim to get around the rule protecting minors. Lord Kenyon emphasised that English law wisely protects minors from contractual liability.

Leslie (R) Ltd. v. Sheill: The King's Bench ruled that a minor cannot be sued in tort for deceit if the effect would be to enforce an unenforceable contract indirectly. Only actual money or property still in the minor's possession could be recovered by way of restitution.

Importance

These cases are standard authorities on the minor's protection in contract law. They show that the law will not let a plaintiff use a tort action, such as negligence or deceit, as a back door to enforce an agreement against a minor, even where the minor has lied about his age. They also explain the limited remedy of restitution. Students should know them when answering questions on a minor's capacity to contract, a minor's fraud about his age, and the relationship between contract and tort liability.

Easy explanation

The law protects children (minors) from being bound by contracts. Two cases show how far this protection goes.

In the first case, a boy hired a horse and rode it too hard, injuring it. The owner could not sue him on the contract because he was a minor. So the owner tried calling it a tort (a civil wrong) instead. The court said no: you cannot change the label from contract to tort just to get around the minor's protection.

In the second case, a young man lied about his age to get a loan. The lender could not sue on the loan because he was a minor. So the lender sued him for fraud (deceit). The court again said no, because making him pay damages for fraud would be the same as making him repay the loan. The lender can only get back money or property that the minor still actually has with him.

Practical example

Hypothetical: Farhan, aged 16, tells Prince that he is 19 and borrows Rs. 50,000 from him. Farhan spends all the money on a holiday. When Prince finds out the truth, he sues Farhan for fraud to get the Rs. 50,000 back. Applying these cases, the claim would fail, because calling it fraud would only be a way of enforcing the loan against a minor. If Farhan had instead used the loan to buy a laptop that he still has, Prince could ask for that specific property to be returned by way of restitution, but he could not claim general compensation.

Key points

  • Jenning v. Rundall (1799): a minor who overrode and injured a hired mare could not be sued in tort for what was really a contract claim.
  • Lord Kenyon: English law wisely protects minors from contractual liability.
  • Leslie (R) Ltd. v. Sheill (1914): a minor who lied about his age to get a loan could not be sued in deceit if that would indirectly enforce the contract.
  • A contract claim cannot be dressed up as a tort claim to make a minor liable.
  • Restitution is allowed only for money or property still in the minor's possession, not as general compensation.

Introduction

These cases reaffirm the protection granted to minors in contract law, emphasizing that minors cannot be held liable for breach of contract and that a contractual claim cannot be converted into a tort claim to impose liability on minors.


Jenning v. Rundall (1799)

Facts

  • A minor hired a mare for a short ride but overrode and injured it.
  • The plaintiff sued under contract law, but the contract was unenforceable due to the minor’s incapacity.
  • The plaintiff then attempted to sue under tort law for the damage caused.

Judgment

  • The court held that a claim founded on a contract cannot be turned into a tort claim to bypass the rule protecting minors.
  • Lord Kenyon emphasized that English law wisely protects minors from contractual liability.

Leslie (R) Ltd. v. Sheill (1914)

Facts

  • A minor fraudulently misrepresented his age to obtain a loan.
  • Since contracts with minors are void, the lender could not sue under contract law.
  • The lender then sued under tort law for deceit.

Judgment

  • The King’s Bench ruled that a minor cannot be sued in tort for deceit if the effect would be to indirectly enforce an unenforceable contract.
  • The court held that only actual money or property still in possession of the minor could be recovered under restitution.

  • Minors are protected from contractual liability – Contracts with minors are void ab initio.
  • Contractual liability cannot be converted into tort liability – Plaintiffs cannot sue in tort to recover damages from a minor for a contract-based claim.
  • Restitution is limited – If the minor no longer possesses the benefit, the plaintiff cannot recover it.

Comparison of the Two Cases

Aspect Jenning v. Rundall (1799) Leslie (R) Ltd. v. Sheill (1914)
Nature of the Case Minor caused property damage and was sued for negligence. Minor fraudulently misrepresented age to obtain a loan.
Plaintiff’s Argument Converted a contract claim into a tort claim. Sued in tort for deceit to recover money.
Court’s Ruling Minors cannot be sued in tort for contract-related claims. Minors cannot be sued for deceit if it enforces an unenforceable contract.
Key Principle Protects minors from indirect contractual liability through tort claims. Only restitution for actual property or money still possessed is allowed.

Conclusion

  • Both cases reaffirm that minors are legally protected from contract enforcement.
  • Court rulings prevent plaintiffs from using tort claims to bypass contract law protections for minors.
  • Restitution is only allowed when the minor still possesses the benefit, not as general compensation.

Test yourself on this case

2 practice questions on this case, with explanations.

A minor hired a mare for a short ride but rode it too hard and injured it. The owner could not sue on the contract because of the minor's incapacity, so he sued in tort for the damage. What was held in Jennings v. Rundall (1799)?

Which of the following statements about R. Leslie Ltd. v. Sheill (1914) is correct?

More Law of Contract I (General Principles) MCQs

115 questions. Every answer comes with an explanation and the legal provision behind it.

Practise now

Make this page yours

Sign in to keep private notes and highlights on this case. Free, and only you can see them.

Judgments

Related cases

Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co.

Law of Contract I (General Principles)

A landmark case on unilateral contracts and acceptance by performance

Law of Contract I (General Principles)

Doraswamy Iyer v. Arunachala Ayyar & Ors.

Madras High Court · 1935

This case examines consideration in contract law under Section 2(d) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 . It addresses whether a promise to contribute to a public cause without any binding obligation is enforceable.

Law of Contract I (General Principles) AIR 1936 Mad 135

Harvey v. Facey

Law of Contract I (General Principles)

Understanding the fine line between an offer and an invitation to treat

Law of Contract I (General Principles)

This case deals with coercion under Section 15 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 , specifically examining whether a threat of criminal prosecution amounts to coercion, thereby rendering a contract void.

Law of Contract I (General Principles)

Study notes

Read the law behind it