Skip to content
The Law Easy

Natural Law School

7 min read Published Updated 72,495 views

Cover: Natural Law School
On this page

Why do we feel that some laws are unfair even when they are properly passed by a legislature? Is a law valid only because the State made it, or must it also be just? The Natural Law School is one of the oldest answers to these questions in Jurisprudence. It says that there are higher, universal principles of right and wrong, and that human laws should follow them. For LL.B. students and exam aspirants, this school is important because it forms the base for later debates on morality, justice and the limits of State power. This article explains its meaning, principles, sources, main thinkers and criticisms in simple language.

1. What is Natural Law School?

The Natural Law School can be understood through four simple points:

  • Definition: It is a philosophical framework asserting that universal principles govern human conduct. In other words, there are certain rules of right behaviour that apply to everyone.
  • Core Belief: These principles are inherent in nature, reason, or divine sources, and they guide the creation of laws. They are not invented by any parliament or king; they already exist and are only discovered.
  • Connection to Morality: Laws must align with moral principles; actions deemed morally wrong should be unlawful.
  • Historical Role: The school has influenced legal thought, integrated morality into law and shaped legal systems.
Key point

For the Natural Law School, law and morality are closely joined. A law is expected to be just, not merely made by an authority.

2. Principles of Natural Law School

The school rests on three main principles:

  • Universal Application: Natural laws apply to all human beings, transcending (going beyond) cultural and societal boundaries. They are not limited to one country, religion or period.
  • Moral Foundation: Natural law is based on concepts like divine law (law believed to come from God), natural rights (rights a person has simply by being human) and inherent justice.
  • Reason as Key: Humans, as rational beings, are expected to discern (recognise) and adhere to these principles through reason.
Example

Hypothetically, Prince lives in a small village in Rajasthan and Hansa lives in a big city in Kerala. Neither has studied law, yet both can understand through reason that killing an innocent person is wrong. A natural law thinker would say this shows a universal principle that applies to all human beings.

3. The Relationship Between Morality and Law

The Natural Law School explains the relationship between morality and law in two ways:

  • Interdependence: Natural law links morality and legal systems, advocating that laws should mirror (reflect) moral standards. Law and morality depend on each other.
  • Legal Framework: Morality provides the basis for lawmaking, ensuring that laws are just and rational.

Put simply, a lawmaker who follows natural law first asks, "Is this rule morally right?" and only then turns it into law.

4. Sources of Natural Law

Different thinkers have pointed to different sources from which natural law comes:

  • God: Many proponents (supporters) attribute the ultimate source of natural law to divine will, that is, the will of God.
  • Nature: Observing the natural order provides insights into what is just and right.
  • Reason: Human intellect is essential for understanding and applying natural law principles.
Note

These three sources are not always separate. Some thinkers combine them, for example by saying that God created nature and gave humans reason to understand it.

5. Division of Natural Law School

For study, the Natural Law School is usually divided into four periods:

  1. Ancient Theories: These originated from thinkers like Socrates and Aristotle and focused on reason and natural justice.
  2. Medieval Theories: Catholic philosophers like Augustine and Aquinas integrated (combined) divine law and natural law.
  3. Renaissance Theories: These emphasised social contracts to escape chaos and establish order. A social contract is the idea that people agree among themselves to form a government and accept its rules in return for security.
  4. Modern Theories: These addressed societal changes, both challenging and reviving natural law concepts.

6. Ancient and Medieval Theories

6.1. Socrates

Socrates believed in innate moral insight, that is, an inborn ability within every person that helps individuals discern right from wrong.

Example

Hypothetically, Farhan finds a wallet belonging to Neha on a bus. Even without thinking about any statute, he feels he should return it. On the Socratic view, this is his inner moral insight at work.

6.2. Aristotle

Aristotle viewed reason as the tool to discover natural justice, emphasising the connection between rationality and law. For him, careful reasoning helps people find what is naturally just.

6.3. Augustine

Augustine linked natural law with Christian values, deriving it from religious texts. In his approach, natural law was closely tied to religious belief.

6.4. Thomas Aquinas

Thomas Aquinas proposed four types of law:

  1. Eternal Law
  2. Natural Law
  3. Human Law
  4. Divine Law

He also asserted that unjust laws lack moral obligation. This means that a person is not morally bound to obey a law that is unjust, even if it has been formally made.

Example

Hypothetically, a ruler passes an order that Zoya must hand over all her savings to the ruler's friends without any reason. Following Aquinas, such an order is unjust, and Zoya would not be under a moral obligation to obey it.

Key point

Remember Aquinas for two things in exams: the four types of law (Eternal, Natural, Human and Divine) and the idea that unjust laws lack moral obligation.

7. Renaissance and Modern Theories

7.1. Thomas Hobbes

Thomas Hobbes advocated absolute sovereignty to ensure order in chaotic states of nature. The "state of nature" means the imagined condition of human life before any government or law existed. For Hobbes, this condition was chaotic, so people needed an absolute sovereign (a ruler with complete power) to keep order.

Example

Hypothetically, imagine a town where there is no police, no court and no government. Aadil fears that anyone may take his house by force. In Hobbes's view, people like Aadil would accept a strong sovereign simply to be safe.

7.2. John Locke

John Locke, unlike Hobbes, believed in a harmonious (peaceful) state of nature. He emphasised property rights and limited government, meaning that a government should have only restricted powers.

7.3. Revival in the 20th Century

In the 20th century, natural law thinking was revived as a response to positivism. Legal positivism, in simple terms, is the view that law is what is laid down by the proper authority, whether or not it is moral. The revival emphasised moral principles during wars and fascist regimes, when it became clear that laws made by those in power could still be deeply unjust.

8. Criticisms of Natural Law School

Despite its influence, the Natural Law School faces several criticisms:

  • Cultural Relativism: Concepts of morality and rationality differ across societies. Cultural relativism means that what is considered right or wrong depends on the culture of a particular society.
  • Practical Challenges: Abstract moral principles are difficult to apply in specific legal contexts.
  • Secularism: Reliance on divine sources is contested in modern, secular societies, where law is not based on any one religion.
Example

Hypothetically, Renu says a certain custom is morally right, while Prince, who comes from a different community, says it is morally wrong. If both claim to rely on "natural law", it becomes hard to decide which view the law should follow. This shows the problem of cultural relativism and of applying abstract principles in practice.

9. Conclusion

The Natural Law School underscores the interplay between morality and law, offering timeless insights into justice and human conduct. From Socrates and Aristotle, through Augustine and Aquinas, to Hobbes, Locke and the 20th-century revival, the central idea remains that law should be guided by higher moral principles. While it faces criticism, its principles remain foundational in ethical and legal discussions worldwide. For exams, remember its core belief, its three sources (God, nature and reason), its four periods and its main criticisms.

Practise Jurisprudence MCQs

114 questions. Every answer comes with an explanation and the legal provision behind it.

Practise now

Make this page yours

Sign in to save your reading progress and keep private notes and highlights. Free, and only you can see them.

Keep reading

Related notes

Jurisprudence

Study of Dharma in the Light of Hindu Jurisprudence

1. Abstract Dharma: A multifaceted concept with varied meanings across Indian religions: Hinduism: Duties, rights, laws, conduct, virtues, and the right way of living. Buddhism: Cosmic law and Buddha’s teachings. Jainis…

7 min read

Jurisprudence

Meaning, Nature, and Scope of Jurisprudence

Meaning of Jurisprudence Origin of the Term: The word "jurisprudence" is derived from the Latin term "juris-prudentia," meaning "knowledge of law." "Juris" refers to law, and "prudentia" refers to skill or knowledge. Wh…

2 min read

Jurisprudence

Contemporary Legal Issues in India

Meaning of Contemporary Legal Issues Definition: Refers to current legal challenges arising due to evolving social, political, economic, and technological factors. These issues require updated laws and policies to addre…

2 min read

Jurisprudence

Schools of Jurisprudence

Focuses on understanding the present form of law, analyzing its structure and components. Also called the Austinian School, Imperative School, or Positivist School.

3 min read

Watch

Related lectures