Quick answer
No. A seller cannot validly ban a buyer from ever selling, mortgaging or gifting the house. Under Section 10 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (TPA), a condition that absolutely restrains the transferee from parting with or disposing of his interest is void. The sale itself stands, and only the condition fails. The main exception is a lease, where a condition for the benefit of the lessor (landlord) is valid.
The law: Section 10, TPA
Where property is transferred subject to a condition or limitation absolutely restraining the transferee, or any person claiming under him, from parting with or disposing of his interest in the property, the condition or limitation is void. Two exceptions are written into the section:
- Leases: the rule does not apply to a lease where the condition is for the benefit of the lessor or those claiming under him.
- Proviso for certain married women: property may be transferred to or for the benefit of a woman (not being a Hindu, Muhammadan or Buddhist) so that she has no power during her marriage to transfer or charge it or her beneficial interest in it.
Essential points
- The key word is "absolutely". Section 10 strikes down a total restraint. Whether a narrower restriction survives depends on its real effect, not on its wording. A clause that in practice leaves the owner no real power to transfer is, in substance, an absolute restraint.
- Only the condition is void. The transfer takes effect as if the condition were not there.
- Why: the power to transfer is an essential part of ownership. A person cannot be given ownership and at the same time be stripped of it.
- Related rules: Section 11 makes a direction to enjoy an absolutely transferred interest "in a particular manner" ineffective against the transferee. Section 12 makes void a condition that the interest will cease if the transferee becomes insolvent or tries to transfer it.
Sale and lease compared
| Point | Transfer of ownership (sale, gift) | Lease |
|---|---|---|
| Absolute ban on transfer | Void under Section 10 | Valid if for the lessor's benefit (exception in Section 10) |
| Default position | Owner may freely transfer | Under Section 108(j), the lessee may transfer or sub-lease his interest, but Section 108 applies only "in the absence of a contract or local usage to the contrary" |
| Reason | Free transfer is part of ownership | The landlord keeps the reversion and has a real interest in who occupies the property |
Farhan sells a house to Aadil. The sale deed says Aadil may never sell, mortgage or gift the house to anyone. The sale is valid, but the condition is void under Section 10, so Aadil can later sell the house to Zoya. In a separate deal, Renu lets her flat to Armaan for five years on the condition that he will not sublet it. That condition benefits Renu as lessor, so it is valid. If Armaan sublets, he breaks the lease.
Current-law note
Section 10, including its lease exception and proviso, is in force in the form summarised above. For other conditions on transfers, see the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 complete notes.
Exam point
An absolute restraint on alienation attached to a transfer of ownership is void, and the transfer stands (Section 10, TPA). A restraint in a lease for the lessor's benefit is valid.