Quick answer
A buyer cannot ignore a person who is living in or using the property. Under Explanation II to Section 3 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (TPA), anyone who acquires immovable property, or any share or interest in it, is deemed to have notice of the title, if any, of the person in actual possession. This is constructive notice (notice the law assumes, whether or not the buyer actually knew). The buyer therefore takes the property subject to whatever valid rights the occupant has.
The law: Section 3, TPA
Section 3 says a person "is said to have notice" of a fact in two situations:
- Actual notice: when he actually knows the fact.
- Constructive notice: when he would have known it but for wilful abstention (deliberately not making) from an enquiry or search he ought to have made, or gross negligence.
Three Explanations then fix specific situations of deemed notice:
- Explanation I (registration): where a transaction relating to immovable property must by law be made by a registered instrument and has been so made, a later acquirer is deemed to have notice of that instrument from the date of registration. This applies only if the registration was completed as the Registration Act, 1908 prescribes, the instrument is entered or filed in the books kept under Section 51 of that Act, and its particulars are correctly entered in the indexes kept under Section 55.
- Explanation II (actual possession): an acquirer of immovable property is deemed to have notice of the title, if any, of any person who is for the time being in actual possession of it.
- Explanation III (agent): notice acquired by an agent while acting for the principal in business to which the fact is material is notice to the principal. The exception is where the agent fraudulently conceals the fact, as against a person who was a party to or knew of the fraud.
Actual and constructive notice compared
| Point | Actual notice | Constructive notice |
|---|---|---|
| Meaning | What the buyer really knows | What the law treats the buyer as knowing |
| Basis | Proof of the buyer's own knowledge | Wilful abstention or gross negligence, or a deemed situation (registration, possession, agent) |
| Can the buyer plead ignorance? | No | No, even if he genuinely did not know |
Points to remember
- The words "if any" matter. Possession does not create a right. It only fixes the buyer with notice of whatever right the occupant really has, such as a tenancy, a mortgage with possession, or an earlier agreement.
- Notice is about actual possession at the time, not about what the seller's documents say.
- A sensible buyer therefore inspects the premises, asks who occupies them and on what basis, reads the title documents and checks the registration records.
Farhan sells a shop to Aadil by a registered sale deed. Armaan is already running his business in the shop under an earlier tenancy granted by Farhan. Aadil never visits the shop and later says he did not know about Armaan. That does not help him. Armaan is in actual possession, so Aadil is deemed to have notice of Armaan's title as a tenant. Aadil takes the shop subject to Armaan's valid tenancy rights.
Current-law note
The TPA definition of notice, including Explanations I to III, is in force. For the general scheme of the Act, see the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 complete notes.
Exam point
Actual possession is notice of the occupant's title (Explanation II, Section 3, TPA). A buyer must investigate both the papers and the possession.