Quick answer
No. Under Section 35 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (the doctrine of election), if a person purports to transfer property that belongs to someone else and, in the same transaction, gives that owner a benefit, the owner must choose. He may confirm the transfer and keep the benefit, or dissent from the transfer, keep his own property and give up the benefit. He cannot take the benefit and reject the burden of the same transaction.
The law: Section 35
Section 35 provides that where a person professes to transfer property which he has no right to transfer, and as part of the same transaction confers a benefit on the owner of that property, the owner must elect either to confirm the transfer or to dissent from it. If he dissents, he must relinquish the benefit, and the benefit reverts to the transferor or his representative. Election (a legal choice between two inconsistent rights) rests on fairness: a person should not approve the helpful part of a document and reject the connected burden.
Essential points
- Same transaction: the attempted transfer of the owner's property and the benefit to the owner must be part of one transaction.
- Transferor's belief does not matter: the rule applies whether or not the transferor believes the property is his own.
- Indirect benefit: a person who takes only an indirect benefit need not elect.
- Different capacities: a person may take a benefit in one capacity and dissent in another.
- Benefit expressly in lieu: where a particular benefit is given expressly in place of the property, an owner who keeps the property gives up only that benefit, not other benefits under the same transaction.
- Compensation to the disappointed transferee: if the transfer is gratuitous and the transferor has died or become incapable of making a fresh transfer before the election, or in every transfer for consideration, the benefit given up is charged with making good to the disappointed transferee the value of the property he was to receive.
- Implied election: accepting the benefit amounts to confirming the transfer if the owner knew of his duty to elect and the relevant circumstances, or waived inquiry. Knowledge is presumed if he enjoys the benefit for two years without dissenting, and may be inferred from acts that make it impossible to restore the original position.
- Time to elect: if the owner does not signify his choice within one year of the transfer, the transferor or his representative may require him to elect; if he does not do so within a reasonable time, he is deemed to have confirmed the transfer.
- Disability: if the owner is under a disability (for example, a minor), the election is postponed until the disability ends or a competent authority elects for him.
Confirm or dissent: the two choices
| Point | Owner confirms the transfer | Owner dissents from the transfer |
|---|---|---|
| His own property | Passes to the transferee | Stays with the owner |
| Benefit under the transaction | Owner keeps it | Owner gives it up; it reverts to the transferor or his representative |
| Disappointed transferee | Gets the property | May be compensated out of the benefit given up, in the cases set out in Section 35 |
Example
A farm worth Rs. 8 lakh belongs to Farhan. By one gift deed, Aadil purports to give that farm to Zoya and also gives Farhan Rs. 10 lakh. Farhan must elect. If he wants the Rs. 10 lakh, he must let the farm go to Zoya. If he keeps the farm, he must give up the Rs. 10 lakh. If Aadil has died before Farhan makes his choice, the Rs. 10 lakh given up is charged with paying Zoya Rs. 8 lakh, the value of the farm she was meant to receive, and the balance reverts to Aadil's representative. The Act's own illustration to Section 35 works the same way with smaller figures.
For a fuller treatment of the doctrine, see Doctrine of Election.
Exam point
Section 35: one who takes a benefit under a transaction must also accept the transfer of his own property made by the same transaction, or give up the benefit. He cannot approbate and reprobate (accept and reject the same instrument).