Quick answer
Sometimes. Under Section 13 of the Indian Easements Act, 1882, when one person transfers or bequeaths land to another, or joint property is partitioned, and a right of way over the land the transferor keeps (or over another share) is necessary for enjoying the land transferred, the transferee gets that right by law. This is an easement of necessity. It arises only where the land cannot be used at all without it, not where it is merely more convenient, and under Section 41 it ends when the necessity ends, for example when another access becomes available.
The law
- Section 4 defines an easement as a right that the owner or occupier of land (the dominant heritage) has, for the beneficial enjoyment of that land, to do something, or prevent something, in or upon other land not his own (the servient heritage).
- Section 13 covers easements arising on transfer, bequest (gift by will) or partition. Clauses (a), (c) and (e) are called easements of necessity: (a) in favour of the transferee or legatee over the transferor's or testator's other land, (c) in favour of the transferor over the land transferred, and (e) in favour of one co-sharer over another's share after partition. The same rule applies where property passes by operation of law.
- Section 14 lets the transferor (or the owner of the share burdened) set out the line of the way of necessity, but it must be reasonably convenient for the dominant owner. If he refuses or neglects, the dominant owner may set it out.
- Section 41 says an easement of necessity is extinguished when the necessity comes to an end.
The leading case
Hero Vinoth (Minor) v. Seshammal, Supreme Court of India, 8 May 2006, (2006) 5 SCC 545, bench of Arijit Pasayat and R.V. Raveendran JJ. The Court explained that an easement of necessity is not one merely needed for reasonable enjoyment, but one without which the dominant land cannot be used at all. It is limited to the barest necessity, and when an alternative access becomes available it is extinguished under Section 41. An easement created by grant (for example, a right of way given expressly in a partition deed) is different: it depends on the terms of the grant and is not extinguished under Section 41 merely because another way exists. The appeal was dismissed because the right of way in that case was a grant.
Easement of necessity and easement by grant compared
| Point | Easement of necessity | Easement by grant |
|---|---|---|
| Source | Implied by law under Section 13 on transfer, bequest or partition | Express or implied agreement of the parties |
| Test | The land cannot be enjoyed at all without it | The terms of the grant |
| Ends when another access appears? | Yes, Section 41 | No, Section 41 does not apply |
Example
Farhan owns a large plot with frontage on a public road. He sells the rear half to Aadil and keeps the front half. The rear half has no other way out except by trespassing on a stranger's land. Aadil is entitled to a right of way over Farhan's front half, and Farhan may choose its line so long as it is reasonably convenient for Aadil. If a new public road later reaches Aadil's plot directly, the necessity ends and the easement is extinguished under Section 41. If Aadil already had another lawful route, even a longer one, no easement of necessity would arise at all.
This mirrors illustration (a) to Section 13 in the Act, where a field sold is inaccessible except over the seller's adjoining land or a stranger's land, and the buyer gets a right of way over the seller's land.
Exam point
Easement of necessity = Section 13(a), (c) and (e) of the Indian Easements Act; it needs absolute necessity, not convenience, and ends with the necessity (Section 41). A right of way by grant does not end merely because another route exists (Hero Vinoth v. Seshammal, 2006).