Quick answer
When two people swap the ownership of one thing for the ownership of another, and the things are either both something other than money or both money only, the transaction is an exchange under Section 118 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, not a sale. A sale under Section 54 is a transfer of ownership for a price (money). Calling it a swap does not avoid formalities: Section 118 says an exchange must be completed in the same manner as a sale of that property, so an exchange of tangible immovable property worth 100 rupees or more needs a registered instrument.
The law: Sections 118 to 121
- Section 118 (definition): two persons mutually transfer the ownership of one thing for the ownership of another, "neither thing or both things being money only". So if neither side is money, or both sides are money (an exchange of money), it is an exchange; if one side gives money only and the other gives property, it is a sale. A transfer in completion of an exchange can be made only in the manner provided for the transfer of such property by sale.
- Section 54 (sale, applied through Section 118): tangible immovable property of the value of 100 rupees and upwards, and a reversion or other intangible thing, can be transferred only by a registered instrument. Below 100 rupees, a registered instrument or delivery of possession is enough.
- Section 119 (defect in title): if a party is deprived of the thing (or part of it) received in exchange because of a defect in the other party's title, then, unless the terms show a contrary intention, the other party is liable for the loss caused, or, at the option of the person deprived, must return the thing he received, if it is still with him, his legal representative or a transferee from him without consideration.
- Section 120 (rights and liabilities): each party has the rights and liabilities of a seller as to what he gives, and of a buyer as to what he takes. So both parties are transferors and transferees at the same time.
- Section 121 (exchange of money): in an exchange of money, each party warrants that the money he gives is genuine.
Sale and exchange compared
| Point | Sale (Section 54) | Exchange (Section 118) |
|---|---|---|
| What is given in return | A price (money) paid, promised or part-paid and part-promised | Ownership of another thing; if only one side gives money, the deal is a sale, not an exchange |
| Roles of the parties | One seller, one buyer | Each party is seller of what he gives and buyer of what he takes (Section 120) |
| Formalities for immovable property | Registered instrument if tangible property is worth 100 rupees or more | Same as sale, because Section 118 adopts the mode of sale |
| Remedy if title fails | Buyer's rights under Section 55 | Compensation for loss or return of the thing given (Section 119) |
Example
Farhan owns a plot in Lucknow and Aadil owns a plot of similar value in Kanpur. They agree that each will become the owner of the other's plot, with no price paid. This is an exchange under Section 118. Because each plot is tangible immovable property worth far more than 100 rupees, the transfer must be made by a registered instrument, just as for a sale; an oral swap or an unregistered paper does not pass ownership. If it later turns out that the Kanpur plot belonged to Aadil's cousin and Farhan is evicted, Section 119 lets Farhan claim compensation from Aadil or, at his option, the return of his own Lucknow plot if Aadil still holds it.
Common mistakes
- Treating a swap as informal: Section 118 expressly applies the formalities of sale.
- Forgetting Section 120: in an exchange, both parties carry a seller's duties (for example, disclosing material defects) for what they give.
For the wider scheme of transfers, see Transfer of Property Act, 1882: Complete Notes.
Exam point
Sale is ownership for a price; exchange is ownership for ownership (Section 118). An exchange must be completed in the same manner as a sale, and Section 119 protects a party who loses the thing received because of the other's defective title.