Skip to content
The Law Easy

Feeding the Grant by Estoppel: Section 43 TPA and Jumma Masjid Case

If a seller wrongly claims authority to sell land and later inherits it, Section 43 TPA lets the buyer claim it, as the Supreme Court held in Jumma Masjid, Mercara (1962).

4 min read Published Updated 13 views

Cover: Feeding the Grant by Estoppel: Section 43 TPA and Jumma Masjid Case

Watch the Short

Seller Did Not Own the Land—But Inherited It Later! Section 43

On this page

Quick answer

Yes, if the conditions of Section 43 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 are met. When a person fraudulently or erroneously represents that he is authorised to transfer immovable property and professes to transfer it for consideration, the transfer will, at the buyer's option, operate on any interest the seller later acquires in that property while the contract of transfer subsists. This rule is called feeding the grant by estoppel. In Jumma Masjid, Mercara v. Kodimaniandra Deviah (1962), the Supreme Court applied it even where the seller, at the time of sale, had only a chance of inheriting.

The law: Section 43

Section 43 provides that where a person fraudulently or erroneously represents that he is authorised to transfer certain immovable property and professes to transfer it for consideration, the transfer shall, at the option of the transferee, operate on any interest which the transferor may acquire in that property at any time during which the contract of transfer subsists. Its second paragraph adds that nothing in the section impairs the right of transferees in good faith for consideration without notice of that option.

The Act's own illustration: A, a Hindu who has separated from his father B, sells three fields to C, representing that he is authorised to transfer them. One field still belonged to B. When B dies, A inherits that field, and C, not having rescinded the contract, may require A to deliver it.

Essential conditions

  • The transferor made a representation, fraudulent or erroneous (mistaken), that he was authorised to transfer the property.
  • The property is immovable.
  • The transfer was made for consideration; a gift is not covered.
  • The transferor later acquires an interest in the same property, for example by inheritance or purchase.
  • The contract of transfer still subsists, that is, it has not been rescinded.
  • The option belongs to the transferee: he may take the later-acquired interest or pursue other remedies.
  • A later bona fide transferee (one who buys in good faith, for value, without notice of the option) is not affected.
Case

Jumma Masjid, Mercara v. Kodimaniandra Deviah, Supreme Court of India, 11 January 1962 (AIR 1962 SC 847), judgment by T.L. Venkatarama Aiyar, J. In 1920 certain reversioners (presumptive heirs) sold properties to Ganapathi, reciting that the properties had already devolved on them, although they then had only a spes successionis (a mere chance of succeeding). One of the sellers, Santhappa, actually became entitled when the widow Gangamma died on 17 February 1933, and in March 1933 he executed a release of the property in favour of the mosque. The Court held that a transferee who takes for consideration, relying on a representation that the transferor has a present transferable interest, gets the benefit of Section 43 even though the transferor had only a chance of succession. Section 6(a), which bars the transfer of such a chance, and Section 43, a rule of estoppel, operate in different fields. The purchaser's successors therefore prevailed over the mosque.

Section 6(a) and Section 43 compared

PointSection 6(a)Section 43
NatureSubstantive bar: the chance of an heir-apparent succeeding cannot be transferredRule of estoppel protecting a misled transferee
Buyer knew he was buying only a chanceTransfer is voidNo protection, because the buyer was not misled
Seller falsely or mistakenly claimed present titleDoes not defeat the buyer's claimTransfer operates on the interest later acquired, at the buyer's option

Example

Example

Armaan sells a field to Neha for Rs. 5 lakh, stating in the sale deed that he is its owner. In fact the field belongs to his father. Later the father dies and Armaan inherits the field. Neha has not rescinded the contract, so she may require Armaan to give her the field under Section 43. If Neha had known all along that Armaan was only a likely heir selling a mere hope of inheritance, she was not misled, and the sale would be void under Section 6(a).

For related transfers by persons without full title, see Transfer of Property Act, 1882: Complete Notes.

Exam point

Exam point

Section 43 feeds a defective transfer with a later-acquired interest only where the transferor represented authority, the transfer was for consideration, the contract subsists, and the transferee chooses to enforce it (Jumma Masjid, Mercara, 1962).

Sources and further reading

Practise Transfer of Property Act, 1882 MCQs

114 questions. Every answer comes with an explanation and the legal provision behind it.

Practise now

Make this page yours

Sign in to save your reading progress and keep private notes and highlights. Free, and only you can see them.

Frequently asked questions

What is feeding the grant by estoppel?

It is the rule in Section 43 TPA. Where a person fraudulently or erroneously represents that he can transfer immovable property and transfers it for consideration, the transfer operates, at the transferee's option, on any interest the transferor later acquires while the contract subsists.

Does Section 43 apply when the seller had only a chance of inheritance?

Yes, if the seller represented a present title and the buyer relied on it and paid consideration. In Jumma Masjid, Mercara v. Kodimaniandra Deviah (1962), the Supreme Court held that Section 6(a) and Section 43 operate in different fields. If the buyer knew it was a mere chance, Section 43 does not help.

Does Section 43 affect a later buyer in good faith?

No. The second paragraph of Section 43 says it does not impair the rights of transferees in good faith for consideration without notice of the earlier transferee's option.

Keep reading

Related notes

Transfer of Property Act, 1882 Case compilation

Landmark Cases in the Transfer of Property Act

Facts: Shantabai’s husband gave her rights through an unregistered document to cut bamboo and teak for 12.5 years. The government took over the forest under a law, and the Forest Officer stopped her.

28 min read

Transfer of Property Act, 1882

Apportionment of Property in India

The term "apportionment" refers to the distribution or allocation of property or income in appropriate shares among claimants. In the context of Indian property law, apportionment is primarily addressed under Sections 3…

10 min read

Transfer of Property Act, 1882

Doctrine of Marshalling and Contribution

The Transfer of Property Act, 1882, under Sections 56, 81, and 82, addresses the doctrines of marshalling and contribution. These doctrines are essential for regulating the rights and responsibilities in property transa…

7 min read

Transfer of Property Act, 1882

Doctrine of Subrogation: Meaning, Case laws and Provisions

Subrogation occurs when one party, often after fulfilling the obligations of another, assumes the legal rights of the creditor against the debtor. This right can arise automatically by law or through the terms of a cont…

9 min read

Transfer of Property Act, 1882

Section 53 of Transfer of Property Act

Section 53 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 addresses the issue of fraudulent transfers of property. A transfer is considered fraudulent if it is made with the intent to defeat or delay creditors or if it is made w…

12 min read

Transfer of Property Act, 1882

Position and Legal Status of Minor in India

A minor is an individual who has not yet reached the legal age of adulthood and, therefore, does not possess the full legal rights and capacities of an adult. In India, a person is generally considered a minor until the…

9 min read

Watch

Related lectures