Quick answer
The title "Leave and Licence Agreement" does not by itself decide whether the occupant is a licensee or a tenant. A lease under Section 105 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 transfers a right to enjoy immovable property, whereas a licence under Section 52 of the Indian Easements Act, 1882 is only a permission that creates no interest in the property. Courts decide which one it is from the real intention of the parties, read from the document as a whole. Exclusive possession is an important clue but not conclusive, as the Supreme Court explained in Delta International Ltd. v. Shyam Sunder Ganeriwalla (1999).
The law
- Lease, Section 105 TPA: a transfer of a right to enjoy immovable property, made for a certain time (express or implied) or in perpetuity, in consideration of a premium or rent.
- Licence, Section 52 Easements Act: a right to do, in or upon the grantor's immovable property, something that would otherwise be unlawful, where the right does not amount to an easement or an interest in the property.
Lease and licence compared
| Point | Lease | Licence |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Transfer of a right to enjoy the property (an interest) | Personal permission; no interest in the property |
| Transferability | The lessee may transfer his interest, absolutely, by mortgage or by sub-lease, unless the contract or local usage provides otherwise (Section 108(j) TPA) | Cannot be transferred by the licensee, except a licence to attend a place of public entertainment (Section 56) |
| Effect of sale by owner | The buyer steps into the lessor's shoes with his rights and, if the lessee so elects, his liabilities (Section 109 TPA) | The grantor's transferee is not, as such, bound by the licence (Section 59) |
| Ending it | By the modes in Section 111 TPA, such as expiry of time or a valid notice | Revocable by the grantor, unless coupled with a transfer of property in force, or the licensee has built a work of a permanent character at his own expense acting on it (Section 60) |
The leading case
Delta International Ltd. v. Shyam Sunder Ganeriwalla, Supreme Court of India, 9 April 1999, (1999) 4 SCC 545, bench of G.B. Pattanaik and M.B. Shah JJ. Dewar's Garage (later merged into Delta International), a monthly tenant of premises in Calcutta used as a petrol service station, gave the station to ESSO under a 1970 deed called "leave and licence". A Single Judge of the Calcutta High Court held it to be a licence; a Division Bench reversed this and treated it as a lease, mainly because of exclusive possession. The Supreme Court set aside the Division Bench, restored the Single Judge's decision and held the deed to be a licence. It said the real intention of the parties must be gathered from the document read as a whole; where it is pleaded or proved that the document is a camouflage (a sham) to evade rent control law, the court will look behind it; and exclusive possession, though very relevant, loses importance where the terms clearly show the parties never meant to create a lease. Here two companies had expressly agreed that the deed would not be treated as a tenancy or lease, and that clause was given due weight.
Tests to apply
- Does the document create an interest in the property (lease), or only permit use while legal possession stays with the owner (licence)?
- Exclusive possession points towards a tenancy, but circumstances may show no lease was intended. These propositions come from Associated Hotels of India Ltd. v. R.N. Kapoor (1960), which Delta quoted.
Example
Farhan lets Aadil occupy his flat for 11 months under a document headed "Leave and Licence". Aadil holds the only keys, pays a monthly sum and Farhan has kept no right to enter. If Aadil pleads and proves that the heading was only a device to avoid rent law, a court may treat him as a tenant despite the heading. Compare a second deal: Farhan lets Neha run a counter inside his own shop, where Farhan keeps the keys, controls the premises and can end the arrangement at will. Read as a whole, that is a personal permission, so it is a licence.
Exam point
Lease = transfer of an interest (Section 105 TPA). Licence = permission without any interest (Section 52 Easements Act). The test is the parties' real intention from the whole document, not its title, and exclusive possession is important but not conclusive (Delta International, 1999).
For other leading property cases, see landmark cases in the Transfer of Property Act.