Quick answer
No. A registered sale deed does not protect a buyer who purchases immovable property while a genuine suit about that property is pending. Under Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (the doctrine of lis pendens, Latin for "a pending lawsuit"), a party to the suit cannot transfer the property so as to affect the rights of the other party under the final decree. The sale is not void, but the buyer takes the property subject to whatever the court finally decides.
The law: Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act
Section 52 says that while a suit or proceeding is pending in a competent court, which is not collusive (not a sham arranged between the parties) and in which a right to immovable property is directly and specifically in question, the property cannot be transferred or otherwise dealt with by any party so as to affect the rights of any other party under the decree or order that may be made, except with the authority of the court and on the terms it imposes.
The Explanation fixes the period of pendency. It begins on the date the plaint is presented or the proceeding is instituted, and continues until the suit is disposed of by a final decree or order and that decree has been fully satisfied, or has become impossible to execute because the limitation period for execution has expired.
Essential ingredients
- A suit or proceeding must be pending in a court of competent jurisdiction.
- The suit must not be collusive.
- A right to immovable property must be directly and specifically in question (a money suit does not attract the section merely because the defendant owns land).
- The property must be transferred or dealt with by a party to the suit during its pendency.
- The transfer must affect the rights of another party under the eventual decree.
- Exception: a transfer made with the court's permission and on its terms.
Two points are often misunderstood. First, the transfer is not void; it is valid between the seller and the buyer, but it gives way to the decree. Second, the section contains no exception for a buyer who did not know about the case. Its purpose is to stop a party from defeating a lawsuit by transferring the disputed property again and again, so the protection does not depend on notice.
Section 52 compared with Section 53
| Point | Section 52 (lis pendens) | Section 53 (fraudulent transfer) |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Protects the outcome of a pending suit | Protects creditors from transfers meant to defeat or delay them |
| Intention | Not required; the section works on pendency alone | Intent to defeat or delay creditors is essential |
| Effect on the transfer | Valid, but subject to the decree | Voidable at the option of a defeated or delayed creditor |
| Good-faith buyer | Not protected merely by good faith or lack of notice | A transferee in good faith and for consideration is protected |
Farhan and Aadil are litigating over who owns a plot. While the suit is pending, Farhan sells the plot to Armaan by a registered sale deed, and Armaan genuinely does not know about the case. The court later decrees that the plot belongs to Aadil. Armaan's purchase cannot defeat that decree: he takes only what Farhan could give, subject to the result of the suit. Any remedy Armaan has lies against Farhan, the seller, not against Aadil.
Procedural support in the Civil Procedure Code
The Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 works alongside Section 52. Under Order XXII Rule 10, a person to whom an interest passes during the suit may, with the court's leave, continue the suit or have it continued against him. Under Order XXI Rule 102, a person to whom the judgment-debtor transferred the property after the suit was instituted cannot use the obstruction provisions (Rules 98 and 100) to resist delivery of possession in execution. For a longer treatment, see Doctrine of Lis Pendens and Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act.
Exam point
A transfer pendente lite (during the suit) is not void; it is subject to the decree, and the buyer's good faith or lack of notice does not save it.