Before a court decides any tort claim, it must answer a basic question: are the right people before it? If the person suing has no capacity to sue, or the person being sued cannot be sued, the case may fail before its merits are even heard. This article explains, in simple terms, who can sue and be sued in tort law, which persons face restrictions, and the key cases students should remember for exams.
Introduction
Capacity refers to the legal status of a person to either sue or be sued under the law. Put simply, capacity answers the question: “Can this person go to court, or be taken to court, for this wrong?”
In tort law, this capacity generally applies to all persons or parties, but it is not absolute. There are reasonable restrictions on who can sue or be sued, and Indian law follows the English law of torts in determining these restrictions.
A party to a tort is anyone directly involved or interested in an act that leads to:
- the commission of a civil wrong, or
- being the victim of such a wrong.
Such persons are referred to as plaintiffs and defendants.
This article discusses the restrictions on who can sue or be sued and explains how a sued person can seek contribution from other joint tortfeasors. A tortfeasor is simply a person who commits a tort. Joint tortfeasors are two or more persons who are together responsible for the same wrong. Contribution means asking the other wrongdoers to share the burden of the compensation.
Parties to Torts
Plaintiff and Defendant
- Plaintiff: A person who initiates a civil suit for recovery against someone who has committed a civil wrong is called the plaintiff.
- Defendant: The defendant is the person who has the right to defend themselves against that suit.
Farhan drives carelessly in Pune and damages Zoya's parked scooter. Zoya files a civil suit against Farhan for compensation. Zoya is the plaintiff, and Farhan, who has the right to defend himself, is the defendant.
Who Counts as a Party?
The term “parties to torts” includes anyone directly interested in the matter who has the right to:
- defend,
- control the proceedings, or
- appeal in court.
Those who do not have these rights are considered strangers or privies to the case.
Suing the Correct Party
One key element is initiating a civil suit against the correct party. The case may not favour the plaintiff if the plaintiff includes:
- the wrong party,
- too many parties, or
- too few parties.
Neha slips on a wet floor in a shop run by Aadil. If Neha files her suit only against Renu, another customer who had nothing to do with the floor, she has sued the wrong party, and her case may not succeed.
Always check two things before a tort suit: does the plaintiff have the capacity to sue, and is the defendant someone who can be sued? Choosing the correct parties is as important as proving the wrong itself.
Who Cannot Be Sued?
The following parties generally cannot be sued, or can be sued only in limited situations:
1. Government
Under Article 300 of the Constitution, the government can be sued in tort and is liable for the acts of its servants in the course of employment like any other employer, but it has been held immune where the act was done in the exercise of sovereign powers. Immunity means protection from being held legally liable. This immunity is therefore limited, not complete. In U.O.I v. Sugrabai (discussed under Key Cases below), the government was held liable for an accident caused by a military driver on duty.
2. Foreign Sovereigns and Ambassadors
A foreign sovereign is the ruler or head of a foreign State, and an ambassador is the official representative of a foreign country. These persons cannot be sued without the central government's permission.
3. Public Officials
Public officials acting within their official capacity may have immunity. “Official capacity” means that the official was doing the work of their office, not acting in a private, personal role.
4. Minors
A minor is a person who has not yet reached the age of majority. Minors can be sued for torts like assault or fraud, but not when intention or knowledge is essential for liability.
Prince, a 16-year-old student, slaps Hansa during a quarrel. Assault is one of the torts for which the rule above says a minor can be sued, so Prince's age alone does not prevent Hansa from suing him.
5. Lunatics (Persons of Unsound Mind)
A person of unsound mind can be sued, and the suit is defended through a guardian appointed by the court (Order XXXII, Rules 3 and 15 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908); lack of mental capacity, that is, being unable to understand what one is doing, may be a defence to some torts.
6. Corporations
A corporation (such as a registered company) is treated by law as a separate legal person. Corporations can be sued for torts committed by their employees, but they are not liable for acts beyond the scope of employment, meaning acts outside the work the employee was employed and authorised to do.
Aadil drives a delivery van for a courier company. While making deliveries, he negligently knocks down Renu. Because Aadil was doing his job, Renu can sue the company. See also Poulton v. London and S.W. Rly. Company below, where the employee acted beyond his authority.
7. Trade Unions
A registered trade union can sue and be sued (Section 13, Trade Unions Act, 1926), and has only limited immunity from tortious claims, that is, claims based on a tort, for certain acts done in contemplation or furtherance of a trade dispute (Section 18).
8. Married Women (Earlier Position)
Previously, married women could not sue or be sued without joining their husbands, but this has changed.
Who Cannot Sue?
Certain individuals are legally disabled from suing. “Legally disabled” here means that the law restricts their right to bring a suit; it has nothing to do with physical disability.
1. Convicts
A convict is a person found guilty of a crime by a court. Convicts were historically barred from suing, but this was changed by the Criminal Justice Act of 1948 (an English statute).
2. Alien Enemies
An alien enemy is a person from a hostile nation. Individuals from hostile nations cannot sue without government permission.
3. Married Women (Earlier Position)
Married women once had no independent legal standing to sue, but this has been reformed.
4. Corporations
Corporations can sue for property-related torts but not for personal wrongs (wrongs against the person).
5. Unincorporated Associations
An unincorporated association is a group of people, such as an informal club, that has not been registered or incorporated as a separate legal body. These groups lack legal personality, which means the law does not treat the group itself as a person, so they cannot sue.
Some residents of a colony in Jaipur run an informal, unregistered cricket club. Since the club has no legal personality, the club itself cannot file a suit in its own name.
6. Minors
Minors cannot sue independently but may do so through a guardian.
Hansa, aged 12, is bitten by Farhan's dog. Hansa cannot file the suit on her own, but her mother, Renu, can bring the suit on her behalf as her guardian.
7. Insolvents
An insolvent is a person who is unable to pay their debts. A receiver is a person appointed to take charge of the property. Insolvents lose the capacity to sue once a receiver is appointed for their property.
Quick Revision Table
Some categories appear in both lists. This table puts them side by side, based on what is stated above:
| Category | Being sued | Suing |
|---|---|---|
| Minors | Can be sued for torts like assault or fraud, but not when intention or knowledge is essential for liability | Cannot sue independently; may sue through a guardian |
| Corporations | Can be sued for torts of employees; not liable for acts beyond the scope of employment | Can sue for property-related torts, not for personal wrongs |
| Married women (earlier) | Could not be sued without joining their husbands; this has changed | Had no independent standing to sue; this has been reformed |
Key Cases
Walmsley v. Humonick: A case involving two young boys playing, where the court ruled in favour of the defendant due to the age and mental capacity of the children involved. Lesson: the age and mental capacity of a child can affect whether liability arises.
U.O.I v. Sugrabai (U.O.I. stands for Union of India): A military driver caused a fatal accident while on duty. The government was held liable because carrying the equipment was not an exercise of sovereign power and could have been entrusted to a private carrier. Lesson: government immunity is not absolute.
Poulton v. London and S.W. Rly. Company: A railway master wrongfully arrested a person beyond his authority, resulting in the corporation not being held liable. Lesson: a corporation is not liable for acts of its employee that go beyond his authority or the scope of his employment.
Conclusion
Understanding who has the capacity to sue or be sued is crucial for determining whether a case is valid in court. Various factors, such as a party's relationship with the state, mental capacity, or the role of public entities, influence these determinations. While laws regarding married women have evolved, other restrictions remain to ensure that only those capable of legal responsibility can sue or be sued.
For quick revision, remember:
- Capacity to sue or be sued is the general rule, but it is subject to reasonable restrictions borrowed from English law.
- The government, foreign sovereigns and ambassadors, public officials, minors, lunatics, corporations and trade unions enjoy full or partial protection from being sued.
- Convicts (historically), alien enemies, corporations (for personal wrongs), unincorporated associations, minors (without a guardian) and insolvents face limits on suing.
- The position of married women has been reformed on both sides.