Quick answer
Not safely. Under Section 53(1) of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, a transfer of immovable property made with intent to defeat or delay the transferor's creditors is voidable (valid until set aside, but liable to be set aside) at the option of any creditor who is defeated or delayed. A creditor's suit to avoid such a transfer must be brought on behalf of, or for the benefit of, all the creditors. A transferee who took the property in good faith and for consideration is protected.
The law: Section 53 of the Transfer of Property Act
Section 53 is headed "Fraudulent transfer" and has two parts.
- Section 53(1): every transfer of immovable property made with intent to defeat or delay the creditors of the transferor is voidable at the option of any creditor so defeated or delayed.
- Section 53(2): every transfer of immovable property made without consideration with intent to defraud a subsequent transferee is voidable at the option of that subsequent transferee. A gratuitous transfer is not presumed fraudulent merely because a later transfer for consideration was made.
Essential points under Section 53(1)
- The property must be immovable.
- There must be an intent to defeat or delay creditors; a genuine transfer does not become fraudulent merely because creditors are left unpaid.
- The transfer is voidable, not void. It stands until a creditor chooses to challenge it and the court sets it aside.
- "Creditor" includes a decree-holder, whether or not he has applied for execution of the decree.
- The suit must be filed on behalf of, or for the benefit of, all the creditors, so one creditor cannot use it to gain a private advantage.
- The rights of a transferee in good faith and for consideration are not impaired.
- The section does not affect any law relating to insolvency.
Section 53(1) compared with Section 53(2)
| Point | Section 53(1) | Section 53(2) |
|---|---|---|
| Who is protected | Creditors of the transferor | A later transferee of the same property |
| Required intention | To defeat or delay creditors | To defraud a subsequent transferee |
| Consideration | The transfer may be with or without consideration | Applies only to a transfer without consideration |
| Who may avoid it | Any creditor defeated or delayed, suing for all creditors | The subsequent transferee |
Farhan owes large sums to Neha and other creditors. Fearing that they will recover from his house, he executes a deed transferring the house to his friend Aadil without any real payment, while continuing to live in it. Neha may sue, on behalf of or for the benefit of all of Farhan's creditors, to have the transfer set aside so that the house remains available to satisfy their claims. If instead Aadil had paid a fair price in good faith, without being part of any scheme to defeat the creditors, his title would be protected.
Current-law note: criminal liability under the B.N.S.
Apart from the civil remedy, a dishonest transfer can also be an offence. Section 320 B.N.S. punishes whoever dishonestly or fraudulently transfers property without adequate consideration, intending to prevent its distribution according to law among his creditors (imprisonment of not less than six months, up to two years, or fine, or both). Section 322 B.N.S. punishes dishonestly executing a deed of transfer that contains a false statement about the consideration or about the person for whose benefit it is really intended. These replace Sections 421 and 423 of the old IPC. For the wider discussion, see Section 53 of Transfer of Property Act.
Exam point
A transfer made to defeat or delay creditors is voidable, not void; the creditor sues for all creditors, and a transferee in good faith for consideration is protected.