Quick answer
The buyer is not left without a remedy. Under Section 55(1)(a) of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, unless the contract provides otherwise, the seller of immovable property must disclose any material defect (one important enough to affect the transaction) in the property or in his title, which he knows of, the buyer does not know of, and the buyer could not discover with ordinary care. Section 55 declares an omission to make this disclosure fraudulent, so the buyer can treat his consent as obtained by fraud.
The law: the seller's duties under Section 55(1)
Section 55 sets out the rights and liabilities of the buyer and seller "in the absence of a contract to the contrary". Before completion, the seller is bound, among other things:
- Clause (a): to disclose any material defect in the property or in his title of which he is aware and the buyer is not, and which the buyer could not discover with ordinary care.
- Clause (b): to produce all documents of title in his possession or power for the buyer's examination, on request.
- Clause (c): to answer, to the best of his information, all relevant questions put by the buyer about the property or the title.
- Clause (d): on payment or tender of the price, to execute a proper conveyance.
- Clause (e): to take care of the property and title documents, as an owner of ordinary prudence would, between the contract and delivery.
The closing paragraph of Section 55 states that an omission to make the disclosures mentioned in paragraph (1), clause (a) (seller) and paragraph (5), clause (a) (buyer) is fraudulent.
Conditions for the seller's duty to disclose
- The defect is material, in the property or in the seller's title.
- The seller knows of it.
- The buyer does not know of it.
- The buyer could not discover it with ordinary care. A defect visible on a normal inspection, or found by a routine search, is not covered.
Seller's duty compared with the buyer's duty
| Point | Seller: Section 55(1)(a) | Buyer: Section 55(5)(a) |
|---|---|---|
| What must be disclosed | Material defects in the property or the seller's title | Facts about the nature or extent of the seller's interest that materially increase its value |
| Knowledge | Seller aware; buyer unaware and could not discover with ordinary care | Buyer aware; buyer has reason to believe the seller is unaware |
| Effect of omission | Fraudulent | Fraudulent |
Link with the Indian Contract Act
Under Section 17 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, mere silence is ordinarily not fraud, unless there is a duty to speak; and fraud includes "any such act or omission as the law specially declares to be fraudulent". Section 55 TPA is such a declaration. Under Section 19 of the Contract Act, a party whose consent was caused by fraud may treat the contract as voidable, or insist on performance and be put in the position he would have been in had the representations been true. The exception in Section 19, that silence does not make a contract voidable if the party could have discovered the truth with ordinary diligence, matches the "ordinary care" limit in Section 55(1)(a).
Farhan knows that a demolition order has been passed against part of his building. Aadil agrees to buy it; the order is not recorded in any document Aadil could find through normal checks, and Farhan says nothing. The defect is material and undiscoverable with ordinary care, so Farhan's omission is fraudulent under Section 55. Aadil may avoid the contract or seek appropriate relief. Had Aadil asked a direct question, Farhan would also have been bound by clause (c) to answer it truthfully to the best of his information.
For the wider rules on sales of immovable property, see Transfer of Property Act, 1882: Complete Notes.
Exam point
Under Section 55(1)(a), a seller must disclose latent material defects he knows of; omitting to do so is declared fraudulent by Section 55 itself.