Quick answer
No. A son cannot sell or transfer his expected share in his living father's own property. Section 6(a) of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (TPA) says that the chance of an heir-apparent succeeding to an estate, the chance of a relation obtaining a legacy on the death of a kinsman, or any other mere possibility of a like nature, cannot be transferred. This bare hope of inheritance is called spes successionis (Latin for "hope of succession"). It gives no present right in the property, so there is nothing to transfer.
The law: Section 6(a), TPA
Section 6 begins: "Property of any kind may be transferred, except as otherwise provided by this Act or by any other law for the time being in force". Clause (a) is the first exception. It covers:
- the chance of an heir-apparent (the person expected to inherit) succeeding to an estate;
- the chance of a relation obtaining a legacy (a gift under a will) on the death of a kinsman; and
- any other mere possibility of a like nature.
Section 5 supports the same idea. A "transfer of property" is an act by which a living person conveys property, in present or in future. A hope that may never become a right is not property that can be conveyed.
Why the hope cannot be sold
- While the owner is alive, the expected heir has no right in the owner's separate property. The owner may sell it, gift it or make a different will.
- The heir may die first, or the law of succession may give the property to someone else.
- So a "sale" by the expected heir is void under Section 6(a). While the owner is alive, the buyer gets no title in the property through it.
- Once the owner dies and the heir actually inherits, the share becomes real property. The heir can then transfer it in the normal way.
Spes successionis and an existing right compared
| Point | Hope of inheritance (spes successionis) | Inherited share after death |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Mere possibility | Existing property right |
| Transferable? | No (Section 6(a), TPA) | Yes, subject to the general law |
| Can the owner defeat it? | Yes, by sale, gift or will | No, it already belongs to the heir |
Farhan owns a house in his own name, bought with his own earnings. His son Aadil tells Armaan, "I will inherit this house one day, so I am selling you my future share today," and takes money from him. The transfer is invalid under Section 6(a). Aadil owns nothing in the house while Farhan is alive, and Farhan is free to sell it or leave it to someone else by will. Armaan gets no title in the house through this deal.
Important qualifications
- Coparcenary property is different. In a Mitakshara Hindu joint family, a son becomes a coparcener (joint owner by birth). Since the 2005 amendment, Section 6(1) of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 makes a daughter a coparcener by birth in the same manner as a son. That is an existing interest by birth, not a mere hope. Section 6(a) of the TPA concerns the bare chance of inheriting property that someone else owns.
- Conduct can still have consequences. Section 6(a) only says the hope cannot be transferred. If an expected heir has, by declaration, act or omission, intentionally made another person believe something and act on that belief, the general rule of estoppel in Section 121 B.S.A. may stop him from later denying it. Whether it applies depends on the facts and the case law.
For the basic idea of what counts as a transfer, see concept of transfer of property.
Exam point
Spes successionis, the mere chance of an heir-apparent inheriting, cannot be transferred (Section 6(a), TPA). A hope is not ownership.