Quick answer
No. A combination of an agreement to sell, a general power of attorney (GPA) and a will does not transfer ownership of immovable property. In Suraj Lamp and Industries Private Limited v. State of Haryana (decided on 11 October 2011), the Supreme Court held that such "SA/GPA/Will" transactions are not sales and do not convey title; immovable property is legally transferred only by a registered deed of conveyance. Each document does something else: the agreement is only a promise, the GPA only appoints an agent, and the will speaks only after death.
The case
Suraj Lamp and Industries Private Limited v. State of Haryana, (2012) 1 SCC 656; AIR 2012 SC 206 (Supreme Court of India, judgment of 11 October 2011, bench of R.V. Raveendran, A.K. Patnaik and H.L. Gokhale, JJ.; opinion by Raveendran, J.): In many property transactions, buyers paid the price but, instead of taking a registered sale deed, received an agreement to sell, a GPA in their favour and a will by the seller, and treated these documents as if ownership had passed. Held: such SA/GPA/Will transactions are not "transfers" or "sales" and do not convey title or create any interest in immovable property. Immovable property can be legally and lawfully transferred only by a registered deed of conveyance, in line with Section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, which requires a registered instrument for the sale of tangible immovable property worth Rs. 100 or more and says that a contract for sale creates no interest in the property. The Court also held that the Delhi High Court's view in Asha M. Jain v. Canara Bank (2001), which had treated power of attorney sales as a recognised mode of transfer, is not good law to that extent.
What the Court left open
- SA/GPA/Will documents can still be treated as an existing agreement of sale. They may be used to seek specific performance or to defend possession under Section 53A, and the parties may complete their title by obtaining a registered deed of conveyance.
- Where such documents had already been accepted and acted upon by development authorities or by municipal or revenue authorities for mutation (change of the name in the records), that action need not be disturbed merely because of this decision.
- The decision does not affect genuine powers of attorney and sale agreements, for example a power of attorney given to a spouse, son, daughter, brother, sister or other relative to manage affairs or to execute a deed of conveyance.
Why each document fails to convey title
- Agreement to sell: Section 54 says a contract for sale does not, of itself, create any interest in or charge on the property. At most it supports a suit for specific performance and, if registered and accompanied by possession, protection under Section 53A.
- General power of attorney: it creates an agency (the attorney acts for the owner); it transfers nothing. Under Section 201 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, an agency ends, among other ways, when the principal revokes it, or when the principal or agent dies or becomes of unsound mind, or the principal is adjudicated insolvent (Section 202 makes an exception where the agent himself has an interest in the subject-matter). As the Court noted, even an irrevocable power of attorney does not transfer title to the grantee.
- Will: under Section 2(h) of the Indian Succession Act, 1925, a will is a declaration of the testator's intention about his property which he desires to take effect after his death. Under Section 62, it can be revoked or altered by its maker at any time while competent. It transfers nothing during the maker's lifetime.
What each document can and cannot do
| Document | What it can do | What it cannot do |
|---|---|---|
| Agreement to sell | Found a claim for specific performance; support Section 53A protection if registered and possession is given | Make the buyer owner |
| General power of attorney | Authorise the attorney to act for the owner, including executing and presenting a proper sale deed if so empowered | Operate as a sale deed itself |
| Will | Pass the property on the testator's death, if not revoked | Transfer present ownership |
| Registered sale deed | Transfer ownership (Section 54) | - |
Renu pays Armaan the full price for a house and receives an agreement to sell, a GPA and a will, but no registered sale deed. Armaan is still the owner. The GPA only makes Renu his agent and can end on his revocation or death, and he can change his will at any time, so Renu's expectation under it may disappear. Even if the GPA were irrevocable, it would not make her the owner. The correct course is for Armaan himself, or an attorney validly authorised by him, to execute and register a sale deed in Renu's favour.
Current-law note
The statutory basis of the rule remains unchanged: Section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act still requires a registered instrument for a sale of tangible immovable property worth Rs. 100 or more, and Section 17(1A) of the Registration Act, 1908 requires agreements relied on for Section 53A (executed on or after 24 September 2001) to be registered. For other leading decisions in this subject, see Landmark Cases in the Transfer of Property Act.
Exam point
Suraj Lamp (2011): an agreement to sell, GPA and will together are not a sale; title to immovable property passes only by a registered deed of conveyance.
Sources and further reading
- Suraj Lamp and Industries (P) Ltd. v. State of Haryana (Supreme Court, 11 October 2011), Indian Kanoon
- The Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (Sections 53A and 54), Indian Kanoon
- The Registration Act, 1908 (Sections 17(1A) and 49), Indian Kanoon
- The Indian Contract Act, 1872 (Sections 201 and 202), Indian Kanoon
- The Indian Succession Act, 1925 (Sections 2(h) and 62), Indian Kanoon