Skip to content
The Law Easy

Case explanation · Media Law

Indibly Creative v Government of West Bengal (2019) | Film Ban by Police Pressure

  • 4 min

The lecture loads from YouTube in privacy-enhanced mode only when you press play.

From the YouTube description

About this lecture

Case 25 of 30 in Law Easy's Media Law series. Indibly Creative Pvt. Ltd. v. Government of West Bengal, Supreme Court of India, decided 2019. FACTS The Bengali political satire Bhobishyoter Bhoot, directed by Anik Dutta, received a UA certificate. Days before its February 2019 release in Kolkata, a senior police officer wrote to the producers demanding a special screening. The day after release the film was pulled from almost all theatres, though no law authorised this. WHAT THE COURT HELD In April 2019, in a judgment by Justice D. Y. Chandrachud, the Supreme Court held that the state had used its police to stop a certified film, an unlawful and unconstitutional restraint. It stressed the state's positive duty to protect free speech and ordered the state to pay 20 lakh rupees as compensation to the producers and 1 lakh rupees as costs. EXAM POINT Courts look at the real effect of official conduct, not only at written orders. Informal pressure can violate freedom of expression. PREVIOUS CASE: Viacom 18 Media v. Union of India - https://youtu.be/pAr0NCYUV5w NEXT CASE: Tata Press Ltd. v. Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Ltd. - https://youtu.be/4gzgLwllKaE FULL PLAYLIST (all 30 cases in order): https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLY-t71WbMh6k COMPLETE LECTURE (all 30 cases, 1 hour 52 minutes): https://youtu.be/8AFvktrLPM4 Made for LL.B. students and for CLAT PG, UGC NET Law and judiciary exam preparation. Subscribe to Law Easy for the full law course. Notes: https://www.thelaweasy.com #MediaLaw #FilmLaw #LawEasy

Notes

Notes on Media Law

All notes on this subject
Media Law Case compilation

Media Law: 30 Important Case Laws

This case tests whether a law protecting journalists can also limit press freedom. Can a newspaper refuse to follow a law that protects its own journalists? If paying proper wages becomes expensive, does that alone make the labour law unconstitutional?

95 min read

Media Law Complete notes

Media Law: Complete Notes

Media Law governs the press, broadcasting, cinema and digital media. Studied in five units, it runs from the history of how the press won its freedom to the ethical choices a journalist must make where the law gives no clear answer. It is at work whenever a person reads a newspaper, watches a news…

122 min read

Practise 118 Media Law MCQs Check what you have learnt with practice questions on this subject.

Video lectures

More on Media Law

All lectures on this subject

Learn with video

Watch every lecture free on YouTube

Complete courses, landmark case explanations and quick Shorts from The Law Easy channel. Subscribe to get new lectures as soon as they are published.